Best American Restaurants in New Hartford
Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
41 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
See what locals rave about
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- VVeronicaGoldNew York City •25 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 29, 2026 Since opening a year ago, we have probably been to Romans no fewer than 20 times and have never been disappointed. The service, food and ambience who’s outstanding. The Wednesday raw bar in the summer has the best raw clams and oysters I’ve ever had.More infoRoman's at the View$$$$• Italian• Utica•4.5
- VValerieGoldNew York City •21 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 26, 2026We visited on a Monday night in October at 6 pm so noise level was a very comfortable level. We started with a dry martini, bourbon on the rocks and a flight of Mezcal. Bartender came tableside to pour the flight and chat about the Mezcal. Delish! Also delish was the filet dinner, the rare tuna entree and the shrimp tacos. (The two tacos were meant to be an app but were plenty as a main). Server offered to add another taco to ‘beef it up to entree portion’ (thank you for offering Kyle) but it was perfect as is. We had a great night with fabulous meals. I’d definitely go back next time we’re in Utica.More infoOcean Blue Restaurant & Oyster Bar$$$$• Seafood• Utica•4.4
- LLynnNew York City •2 reviews4.0Dined on Oct 24, 2026We were promptly seated and our dining options were explained. Placing our orders for cocktails, starters and main courses, our selections were provided quickly but giving us enough time to enjoy each entree. We found the restaurant quiet enough to converse easily as it filled quickly with other patrons. Our wait staff was attentive and efficient. We enjoyed our meal and will consider returning.More infoMotus$$$$• American• Utica•4.7
- JJamesGoldNew York City •16 reviews4.0Dined on Sep 27, 2026Hostess wasn’t aware you could make OpenTable reservations. We were seated promptly and placed drink and app order. Drinks and bread arrived shortly afterwards. They offer a daily early bird special(as of 9/26) from 3-5:30 daily. Consists of drinks - sodas, tea/coffee; soup or salad and choice of 6 entrees from 2 different price structures. Also included is a bowl of chocolate or vanilla ice cream or mini cannoli. Ordered the deluxe app - Buratta with fresh tomatoes, onions and fresh basil. Soup we picked: minestrone and Chickarina; entrees: Fettuccine Alfredo and grilled Alpine chicken. Dessert was the cannolis. Great value, food was tasty and service was excellent. Adding to our restaurants when we are in the Utica area.More infoCarmella's Cafe$$$$• Italian• Utica•3.6
- MMarkUpstate New York •6 reviews5.0Dined on Jul 10, 2026Great experience all around. Service was excellent.More infoRed Lobster - New Hartford$$$$• Seafood• Utica•4.4