Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Middle Island

Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

45 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of The Farm Italy Restaurant Westbury NY restaurant
1. The Farm Italy Restaurant Westbury NY
4.7
Exceptional(554)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • East Garden City
Booked 84 times today
The Farm Italy Restaurant opens its second New York location in Westbury, NY. Recently named one of Opentable's Top 100 Restaurants in the U.S., The Farm Italy is known for its handcrafted Italian cuisine, exceptional hospitality, and stunning spaces that transport guests straight to the Italian countryside.
A photo of Pasta Pasta restaurant
2. Pasta Pasta
4.8
Exceptional(2211)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • Port Jefferson
Booked 24 times today
Pasta Pasta in the charming town of Port Jefferson is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. The restaurant boasts a menu that features the freshest catches, ensuring a delightful and authentic seafood experience. Diners rave about the "consistently excellent" quality of the seafood dishes, noting the impeccable preparation and presentation. The ambiance, reminiscent of a Tuscan villa, enhances the dining experience, making it both romantic and inviting. Guests frequently describe the service as "outstanding," and the seafood as "delicious" and "perfectly cooked." Whether you're in the mood for a casual meal or a special celebration, Pasta Pasta promises a seafood feast that will not disappoint.
A photo of Legacy Room restaurant
3. Legacy Room
3.3
Good(17)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • Patchogue
Booked 5 times today
Legacy Room is a hidden gem in Patchogue, NY—a small, cozy sanctuary just steps from the tranquil waters of the Great South Bay, offering an intimate escape without the bustle of the coast.Led by Chef Mike Artist, the menu features modern dishes and spins on old classics like Beef Wellington crafted with premium ingredients and plated with true artistry—each creation a visual masterpiece that’s as delightful to admire as it is to savor.Come experience thoughtful, elevated cuisine in a space designed for lingering conversations and unforgettable moments.een upscale and relaxed, blending nautical charm with modern elegance. Whether you’re stopping in for sunset cocktails, a romantic dinner, or a weekend lunch by the bay, Legacy Room promises an unforgettable dining experience.
A photo of La Volpe Ristorante restaurant
4. La Volpe Ristorante
4.8
Exceptional(968)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • Center Moriches
Booked 8 times today
Nestled in the heart of Center Moriches, La Volpe Ristorante offers an exceptional Contemporary Italian dining experience that has captivated locals and visitors alike. Celebrated for its "fantastic culinary adventure" and the perfect marriage of Executive Chef Franco Volpe's "creative contemporary style" with his mother Maria Teresa's cherished traditional recipes, this restaurant is truly a gem. Guests rave about the "excellent food and service," highlighting the fresh seafood, all-natural meats, and hearty pastas that grace the eclectic menu. The inviting atmosphere paired with an "award-winning wine list" ensures that each visit is memorable, making La Volpe a must-visit destination for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.
A photo of Strega - New Haven restaurant
5. Strega - New Haven
4.9
Exceptional(175)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • New Haven
Strega in New Haven is a shining star of Contemporary Italian cuisine, offering an experience that effortlessly marries tradition with modern flair. With dishes described as "absolutely delicious" and "creative and so delicious," the restaurant has captured the hearts of diners seeking an authentic Italian experience. Strega’s commitment to using imported Italian products ensures the flavors are as genuine as they are exquisite. The gnocchi has been hailed as "the best I've ever had," a testament to their dedication to quality. The ambiance, paired with impeccable service, makes Strega a must-visit destination for anyone craving a taste of Italy in New Haven.
A photo of Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge restaurant
6. Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge
4.7
Exceptional(644)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • Hauppauge
Booked 15 times today
At Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge, the fish dishes are truly a standout, earning rave reviews for their "scrumptious" flavors and freshness. Nestled in Hauppauge, this Italian gem is celebrated for its authentic and quality fish cuisine. Diners rave about the "special pasta with crab meat and shrimp," which captures the essence of Italian coastal flavors with finesse. It's no wonder patrons return time and again, as the restaurant consistently delivers "amazing" meals that are both delicious and memorable. If you're craving authentic Italian fish dishes, Steve's Piccola Bussola promises an "outstanding" dining experience that you won’t soon forget.
A photo of Bar Lucy restaurant
7. Bar Lucy
4.7
Exceptional(1006)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • Bay Shore
Booked 19 times today
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails in Bay Shore is a standout in the realm of Gastro Pub cuisine, offering "consistently delicious food" that perfectly complements its thoughtfully crafted cocktails and vibrant atmosphere. This American Gastropub creates an inviting ambiance with its "beautifully presented" dishes, such as the grilled octopus and signature meatloaf, which have earned high praise from diners. The Linwood excels in providing an exceptional dining experience, described by patrons as "a South Shore gem" with superb menu selections that never fail to impress. The "friendly, professional" staff add to the charm, making every visit memorable and worth repeating.
A photo of Gioia restaurant
8. Gioia
4.7
Exceptional(452)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • Oyster Bay
Booked 16 times today
Gioia in Oyster Bay, New York, is a remarkable haven for lovers of Contemporary Italian cuisine, particularly celebrating the flavors of Emilia-Romagna. Revered for its handmade pasta and seasonal vegetable dishes, Gioia creates a dining experience that is both "joyous" and authentically Italian. The restaurant boasts an "authentic feel," with a cozy ambiance and dim lighting that perfectly complement its delicious offerings. Diners rave about the "fantastic service" and innovative menu, featuring standout dishes like the mushroom lasagna and lobster tagliatelle. With glowing reviews highlighting its "sublime culinary experience," Gioia promises a delightful escape into the heart of Italy.
A photo of Iavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria restaurant
9. Iavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria
4.7
Exceptional(1131)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • Plainview
Booked 50 times today
Iavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria in Plainview is a shining star in the world of Contemporary Italian cuisine, offering diners a delightful blend of traditional and modern flavors. This family-friendly trattoria is celebrated for its "excellent food and amazing service," making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The restaurant's sensational pizzas, classic pasta dishes, and homemade desserts are consistently praised as "delicious" and "satisfying." Guests can enjoy their meals in a cozy dining room or a charming year-round atrium. With a welcoming atmosphere and "outstanding" service, Iavarone promises an exceptional dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.
A photo of L'Orcio restaurant
10. L'Orcio
4.9
Exceptional(2337)
$$$$
• Contemporary italian • New Haven
Booked 21 times today
RESERVATIONS:Garden Tables - Outdoor DiningStandard Tables- Indoor DiningL'Orcio is an upscale dining establishment serving Contemporary Italian Cuisine. In house made specialty pastas like Ricotta Gnocchi, Papparedelle and Ravioli are only part of the L'Orcio experience. Chef d'Amuri, an Italian native, also works his magic grilling whole fish and juicy steaks and offers a variety of meat and fish dishes daily. Desserts like Tiramisu', Charlotte agli Amaretti and Lemon Tart are also prepared in house. A relaxing and elegant ambiance with a European flair is the perfect backdrop for lunch, dinner or spirits. Located in a refurbished historical home the restaurant offers a unique space their guests. Family owned and operated with an eye for detail L'Orcio has a lot to offer. Come in for a meal, a drink or just to say Ciao.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • RoseGold
    New York City •8 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 2 days ago
    I always love going to Steve’s Piccolo Bussola. Is consistently delicious service is excellent. I love it. It really is my go to.
    More info
    Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge$$$$• Italian• Hauppauge
    •
    4.7
  • Susan
    New York City •1 review
    5.0
    Dined 3 days ago
    excellent meal. They were very helpful, especially for the gluten free diner. Will definitely go again.
    More info
    Strega - New Haven$$$$• Italian• New Haven
    •
    4.9
  • Will
    New York City •1 review
    5.0
    Dined on May 1, 2026
    Pasta Pasta is far & away my favorite restaurant in Port Jeff! Service, food, and atmosphere are all sublime, can’t recommend enough!
    More info
    Pasta Pasta$$$$• Contemporary Italian• Port Jefferson
    •
    4.8
  • Mary
    New York City •10 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on Apr 22, 2026
    La Volpe is an Italian treasure in Center Moriches. The food is always outstanding, the service impeccable, and the ambiance is cozy and thematic. You are never rushed. As a diner, you are able to savor the food in a relaxed setting. The toasted almond tiramisu is so light yet bursts with flavor. I very much enjoy the tuna appetizer and the lobster ravioli with shrimp and bay scallops. The sauce is creamy and perfectly accompanies the seafood. My husband enjoys their veal dishes. I went with a friend last night who had traditional chicken parmigiana. Also delicious. If you want an exceptional dining experience, you should visit La Volpe.
    More info
    La Volpe Ristorante$$$$• Italian• Center Moriches
    •
    4.8
  • KaraGold
    Orlando / Central Florida East •1 review
    5.0
    Dined on Mar 13, 2026
    Food and drinks were amazing! Great atmosphere. Excellent service!! Can’t wait to come back!
    More info
    Legacy Room$$$$• Contemporary American• Patchogue
    •
    3.3

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2026 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo