Best Continental Restaurants in Brewster

Josh, the bartender was amazing! He provided a lot of recommendation on food, drinks and the nearby area. We ended up going back the next night too since he was so nice! Food was also great!

The experience last evening was absolutely superb. The service, the ambiance, the presentation - all spectacular. Arethusa is on it's game and has set the standard. Photograph-worthy presentation with the taste to match. Every aspect was memorable and we are still talking about it! Our regards to the Arethusa al Tavolo Host, Peter.

Great music - love Dom and Nick! Great food always. Great service from Isabella.

Great food and service, one of our favorite restaurants.

We celebrated a belated anniversary dinner at Chef Luis with friends who are foodies, and the evening could not have been more delightful. Our friends were genuinely impressed — the dishes, the cocktails, and the entire atmosphere won them over completely, and they said without hesitation that they’ll be returning. Chef Luis himself stopped by our table, adding a personal touch that made us feel especially welcome. It was a wonderful experience from start to finish.