Best Farm To Table Restaurants in Shelter Island

Admin and Judy’s was a very pleasant surprise. I’ve dined at many restaurants in the Hamptons over the years and this by far is my favorite. I know that is saying a lot but this restaurant deserves the recognition. Every aspect of our meal was perfect- the cocktails, perfectly cooked steaks, a nice lightly dressed salad, crispy fries and a light dessert. The staff were attentive and kind and the ambiance was refreshing. I will come back again and again!

Our server Michael was friendly and professional yet personable. Our food was great, the onion rings were phenomenal!

Our 1st time and enjoyed every part of our evening. My husband ordered the pork chop and couldn’t have been more pleased , I ordered the halibut and was also very please. The service was great and we will be going back.

Great food and service in a beautiful setting. It was a treat!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ We had an amazing dinner at Nourish by The Roundtree. From the moment we arrived, the hospitality was warm and welcoming, and the entire experience felt very thoughtful and well executed. The food was excellent — fresh, flavorful, beautifully presented, and clearly made with quality ingredients. Every dish we ordered was delicious, and the menu had a great balance of healthy, creative, and satisfying options. The service was attentive without being intrusive, and the atmosphere was comfortable and elegant. It’s the kind of place where you can really relax, enjoy a great meal, and take your time. Overall, a wonderful dinner experience. We’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend Nourish by The Roundtree to anyone looking for great food and genuine hospitality in Bridgehampton.