11 Best Italian Restaurants In Mayfield

11 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Casa Nova Italian Restaurant & Bar, Honeysuckle restaurant

1. Casa Nova Italian Restaurant & Bar, Honeysuckle

3.8

Excellent(49)

$$$$

• Italian • Newcastle CBD

Booked 24 times today

All of our food was delicious, table service was 10/10. Staff were all lovely and helpful. Food and drinks arrived promptly not a long wait at all. We had a great date night and wait to come back again.

2. Sapori at Tailors

4.8

Exceptional(96)

$$$$

• Italian • Islington

Booked 7 times today

We loved our Sapori dining experience. Their food, friendly service and ambiance is so wonderful and made us feel at home. We would highly recommend couples and small groups for a superb time at this restaurant. Excellent 👌👍

A photo of Urban Restaurant & Wine Bar restaurant

3. Urban Restaurant & Wine Bar

4.8

Exceptional(54)

$$$$

• Italian • Cooks Hill

Booked 5 times today

Great experience at Urban. Small friendly restaurant. Friendly staff. Great food.

A photo of Hungry Wolfs Italian Restaurant restaurant

4. Hungry Wolfs Italian Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(20)

$$$$

• Italian • Islington

Booked 1 time today

Food was delicious, service faultless and friendly. Great night out :)

5. The Colliery Inn

4.5

Awesome(1)

$$$$

• Italian • Wallsend

The Colliery Inn has a cosy atmosphere. The food was high-quality. I had a steak and it was tender and cooked to my request. The service was prompt and friendly and there is a good choice of beverages at the bar.

A photo of The Wild Flower Bar & Dining at Bells at Killcare restaurant

6. The Wild Flower Bar & Dining at Bells at Killcare

4.7

Exceptional(827)

$$$$

• Italian • Killcare Heights

Booked 8 times today

This is a central coast gem that’s top notch quality on all fronts. Food is spectacular and the portions are quite substantial. Service friendly and attentive. We ordered from the standard menu but many around us ordered the Sunday feast which was a roast. My father said it’s one of the best steaks he’s had and the desserts were varied and delicious. Definitely add it to your list if you’ve not been.

A photo of Casa Nova Italian Restaurant & Bar, Green Hills restaurant

7. Casa Nova Italian Restaurant & Bar, Green Hills

4.3

Awesome(24)

$$$$

• Italian • East Maitland

Booked 12 times today

We came in for the Monday bottomless pasta deal and our waitress Shania was so lovely! She was very attentive despite having a busy section (which she managed well). Friendly, professional and sincere, even when the kitchen was busy. She checked on us throughout the meal and looked after the table well, upselling aditional drinks and organising the next round of pasta. As someone who has worked in hospitality entirely too long, I was quite impressed. Shania is an absolute credit to your restaurant, a genuine gem.

A photo of Amalfi Ettalong Beach restaurant

8. Amalfi Ettalong Beach

4.2

Awesome(393)

$$$$

• Italian • Pearl Beach

Booked 18 times today

Truly couldn’t find a fault about our meal yesterday evening. The service was amazing from start to finish and our food came quickly and was delicious. Such a great dining experience, we will be back!

A photo of Casa Nova Italian Restaurant and Bar Toronto restaurant

9. Casa Nova Italian Restaurant and Bar Toronto

4.5

Awesome(26)

$$$$

• Italian • City of Lake Macquarie

Booked 8 times today

the staff here were all very friendly, they were accomodating to me as a vegan and the vegan pizza was AMAZING! it was a little loud inside but understandably so, and from where we were sitting we could still have a view of the water without being seated outside. we will definitely be back. thank you!

10. Lagune Artisan

4.5

Awesome(121)

$$$$

• Italian • Wamberal

Booked 9 times today

The best place to eat in Wamberal - Amazing food - exceptional service and I even got some tips off the Pizza Chef on making the perfect base - So glad we have a great local Italian Restaurant.

Best Italian Restaurants in Mayfield

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

11 restaurants available nearby

1. Casa Nova Italian Restaurant & Bar, Honeysuckle

2. Sapori at Tailors

3. Urban Restaurant & Wine Bar

4. Hungry Wolfs Italian Restaurant

5. The Colliery Inn

6. The Wild Flower Bar & Dining at Bells at Killcare

7. Casa Nova Italian Restaurant & Bar, Green Hills

8. Amalfi Ettalong Beach

9. Casa Nova Italian Restaurant and Bar Toronto

10. Lagune Artisan

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable