Best Pizza Bars in Carnegie Hill

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Regions

BergenBronxBrooklynEssexFairfieldHudson

Neighborhoods

BelmontBensonhurstBrooklyn HeightsCedar GroveClinton HillCloster

Top Rated

CharmingFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

51 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. BarDough NYC

4.9

Exceptional(415)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 12 times today

BarDough NYC, nestled in the vibrant Hell's Kitchen, is a gem for authentic Pizzeria cuisine. Praised for its "delicious thin crust pizzas" and described as having "the best pizza we have ever had," this family-run restaurant offers an inviting escape on Restaurant Row. Diners rave about the "amazing service and atmosphere," making it a perfect spot for a pre-theater meal or a casual night out. The cozy setting is complemented by a lively ambiance and outstanding service, ensuring every visit is memorable. Whether savoring the famous Margherita or indulging in gluten-free options, BarDough promises a delightful culinary journey.

A photo of Sofia's of Little Italy restaurant

2. Sofia's of Little Italy

4.4

Awesome(110)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Little Italy

Booked 6 times today

Sofia's of Little Italy is an exceptional destination for authentic Pizza Bar cuisine, located in the vibrant heart of Little Italy, NYC. Under the expert guidance of Chef Andrea, the pizzas here are a true testament to Italian tradition, crafted with fresh ingredients and skillful techniques that transport diners straight to Italy. Guests rave about the "deliciously fresh and authentic" flavors, with pizzas that are "made to order" and sure to delight every palate. The lively ambiance, coupled with attentive service, makes Sofia's not just a meal, but an experience. It's a must-visit for anyone craving genuine Italian pizza perfection.

3. Angelo's Pizza

4.4

Awesome(569)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 11 times today

Angelo's Pizza in Hell's Kitchen, New York, offers an unparalleled Pizza Bar experience that draws both locals and visitors alike. Their Coal Oven Pizza is renowned for its authentic, crisp, and perfectly charred crust, which creates a "best pizza ever" sentiment among patrons. Conveniently located near Broadway theaters, it's the ideal spot for a pre or post-show meal. With rave reviews highlighting the "absolutely delicious pizza" and "amazing food," Angelo's consistently delivers exceptional service and generous portions that leave diners satisfied. The vibrant atmosphere and attentive staff make every dining experience memorable, ensuring you'll want to return for more.

A photo of Rosemary's Midtown restaurant

4. Rosemary's Midtown

4.6

Exceptional(122)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Midtown East

Booked 87 times today

Rosemary’s Midtown is a neighborhood Italian restaurant located on the corner of Third Avenue & 50th Street. A short walk from the UN, Rockefeller Center, & Midtown offices, it’s a warm & welcoming spot for lunch breaks, after-work cocktails, pre-theater dinners, & weekend brunches.Inspired by the Italian countryside & powered by seasonal ingredients, our menu features house made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, fresh salads, & comforting classics. Favorites include the Rigatoni Arrabbiata, Pappardelle Verde, Steak Tagliata, along with signature pizzas like the Soppressata with hot honey & Mushroom & Sausage. Lighter options like the Chopped Salad ‘Siciliana’ & Lani’s Market Greens make it easy to eat well, any time of day. Whether you’re dining inside our airy main dining room, tucked away in the private dining room, or enjoying the energy of Midtown on our outdoor patio, Rosemary’s offers a true taste of Italy in the heart of Manhattan.

5. Serafina Broadway

4.4

Awesome(2741)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Midtown West

Booked 56 times today

Serafina Broadway, nestled in Midtown West, New York, is the pinnacle of exquisite Pizza Bar cuisine. With an ambiance inspired by classic Fellini films and the vibrant spirit of Broadway, this restaurant offers a dining experience that is both authentic and enchanting. Patrons rave about their "Quattro Formaggio pizza," which is described as "amazing" and a must-try for any pizza aficionado. The pizzas here are crafted with the freshest ingredients, delivering unparalleled taste that resonates with both theater-goers and local Italian food enthusiasts. With its rustic charm and consistently delightful offerings, Serafina Broadway is truly a gem in the heart of the city.

6. Fumo Upper West

4.7

Exceptional(245)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Upper West Side

Booked 38 times today

Welcome to Fumo. Our strong Italian roots & love for fresh, homemade food is evident in every dish. Simply simple & authentic. Enjoy.

A photo of Napoletano Wood Fired Tavern restaurant

7. Napoletano Wood Fired Tavern

4.5

Awesome(59)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • River Vale

Booked 1 time today

NAPOLETANO WOOD FIRED TAVERN located in River Vale NJThe vision was to create a unique restaurant experience that can provide the rich tradition of a classic Neapolitan pizza, premium seafood, Italian specialties, and other unique flavors from around the world to our guests in a relaxed and comfortable atmosphere. To accomplish this, we have assembled an outstanding staff and use only the finest ingredients and food products.

8. Rosemary's East

4.7

Exceptional(102)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Kips Bay

Booked 40 times today

Rosemary's East is a vibrant Italian restaurant located on Manhattan's East Side on the edge of Stuytown. This neighborhood gem offers a warm atmosphere ideal for casual lunches, romantic dinners, trendy brunches, or lively gatherings. At Rosemary's East, we pride ourselves on using fresh, seasonal ingredients. Our menu features a delightful selection of hand-crafted pasta, pizzas, salads, and classic Italian dishes, all made with the finest local produce and imported specialties. Indulge in our signature housemade pasta dishes like Rigatoni alla Vodka, Cacio e Pepe, or Pappardelle Verde. Don't miss our wood-fired pizzas, including the classic Margherita, flavorful Mushroom & Spinach, and unique Soppressata with honey. For a lighter option, try our refreshing salads such as the Chopped Salad 'Siciliana' or Lani's Market Greens. Come experience a taste of Italy right in NYC in one our many dining rooms our outdoor patio. Nearby to Stuytown, Kips Bay, and Gramercy Park.

A photo of Serafina Upper West restaurant

9. Serafina Upper West

4.6

Exceptional(1154)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Upper West Side

Booked 25 times today

Serafina Upper West is a standout destination for authentic Pizza Bar cuisine in the vibrant Upper West Side of New York. The pizza oven takes center stage, crafting perfectly thin and crispy pizzas that are frequently praised as "delicious" and "a must-try." The lively atmosphere, complemented by vibrant frescos, adds to the dining experience, making it ideal for families and professionals alike. Guests consistently highlight the "amazing food" and "excellent service," creating a welcoming environment that keeps diners returning. Whether you're enjoying a leisurely meal or grabbing a pre-show bite, Serafina promises a delightful experience with its exceptional and consistent offerings.

10. Serafina 38th

4.5

Awesome(568)

$$$$

• Pizza Bar • Murray Hill

Booked 39 times today

Serafina 38th in Murray Hill, New York, is a standout destination for authentic Pizza Bar cuisine, priding itself on sourcing the finest ingredients from around the globe. This commitment to quality shines through in every bite, making each pizza an "amazing" experience that diners rave about. Guests consistently highlight the "excellent food" and "fantastic service," creating an inviting atmosphere that feels both lively and welcoming. The Margherita pizza, a crowd favorite, captures the essence of traditional Italian flavors, making it a must-try for pizza enthusiasts. With its vibrant ambiance and delicious offerings, Serafina 38th is truly a neighborhood gem.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

S
SaraGold
New York City •32 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
I cannot say enough things about the waitstaff, the bus boys and the host staff! We were there for Mother’s Day and we were sat on time, attentively serviced and every request honored with a smile. Food was wonderful, but Service was even better! This was our second time at this location, but we were serviced in an equally wonderful manner at another location as well. The management of Rosemary‘s should be very proud of the people that they are hiring.
More info
Rosemary's East$$$$• Italian• Kips Bay
•
4.7
T
Talia
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Great service and food!! Will definitely come back!
More info
BarDough NYC$$$$• Pizza Bar• Hell's Kitchen
•
4.9
E
ESharonGold
New York City •15 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Delicious food; perfect location for gathering with friends to dine and catchup. Left overs are just as delicious the next day.
More info
Angelo's Pizza$$$$• Pizzeria• Hell's Kitchen
•
4.4
D
daveGold
Philadelphia County •53 reviews
5.0
Dined on Apr 15, 2026
DELICIOUS FOOD. APPETIZERS AND ENTREES. VERY SATISFIED
More info
Sofia's of Little Italy$$$$• Italian• Little Italy
•
4.4
M
Matt
New York City •6 reviews
5.0
Dined on Apr 10, 2026
Really good menu for the whole family. A step up from average Italian, many great options and everything we had was delicious with generous portions. Pricing feels totally reasonable too. The wine options are the right kind of limited with reasonable prices. Cool place, I think it can become a place that folks go back to often if they can maintain consistency.
More info
Napoletano Wood Fired Tavern$$$$• Pizza Bar• River Vale
•
4.5

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Pizza Bar Cuisine

Carnegie Hill

Midwood
NoHo
East Flatbush
Rockefeller Center
Chinatown
Forest Hills
Bayside
Meatpacking District
Theater District
Financial District
NoLita
Battery Park City
NoMad
Upper West Side
South Street Seaport
Greenwich Village
Yorkville
Rockaway Park
Hudson Yards
East New York