6 Best Pizzerias In Margaretville

6 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. The Kaatskeller

4.4

Awesome(29)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Livingston Manor

We wanted to capture the Catskills experience all in one place, and that’s just what we set out to do with The Kaatskeller. You can socialize and relax outside with friends over a game of bocce or chill out indoors with a comforting craft cocktail in front of our fireplace. Whether you’re dining inside or out, our hand-tossed wood-fired pizzas will hit the spot and capture the fresh, bold flavors we’re known for - using ingredients from local farms to make sure you’re getting a genuine taste of the Catskills.

2. Lola Pizza

(0)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Kingston

Coming Soon!

A photo of Woodstock Pizza Theater restaurant

3. Woodstock Pizza Theater

4.0

Excellent(26)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Woodstock, New York

For the love of food,Welcome to Woodstock Pizza Theater, home to the Hudson Valley’s best wood-fired Napolitano pizza and Italian cuisine. Everything at Woodstock Pizza Theateris designed with the guest in mind. You will enjoy a memorable dining experience, with impeccable service and food that is freshly prepared. We pride ourselves in providing bold flavors using only the freshest, locally sourced ingredients that will excite the senses and guarantee you'll be back again and again. Woodstock Pizza Theater is a relaxed, hip and comfortable atmosphere to enjoy any one our specialty dishes.Woodstock Pizza Theater is a neighborhood restaurant where you can stop by with friends and family for a full meal or just to enjoy some of our lighter bites. We want our guests to be fully satisfied and strive to deliver and exceed their expectations every day. So sit back, relax and allow us to entertain and delight you with our food. You will not be disappointed.

A photo of Carbonella's Coal Fired Pizza restaurant

4. Carbonella's Coal Fired Pizza

(0)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Middletown

Carbonella's Coal Fired Pizza is a popular pizza joint in lovely Middletown, New York. This family-friendly restaurant is warm and inviting. The dining room is decorated with numerous wall-mounted TVs, contemporary artwork, a plethora of sports memorabeilia and large windows. The dark and detailed ceiling is lined with modern pot lights, and the room is full of table and booth seating. During the warm spring and summer months, Carbonella's Coal Fired Pizza also provides guests the option of dining outside on the well-kept patio. All pizzas made at Carbonella's Coal Fired Pizza are made in a coal fire oven. The menu consists of an impressive list of options including Margherita pizza, Grandma pie, Philly cheesesteak pizza and sweet and spicy pizza.

5. Old School Farm

4.9

Exceptional(3)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Honesdale

People the world over have been cooking in earthen domes for thousands of years. By creating a well-insulated earth oven, heat can be trapped for many hours in the fire bricks, sand filled base, and surrounding clay. As the earth oven slowly cools, different foods can be baked. Our "Open Farm" events focus a favorite - wood-fired pizza, and this helps connect children with growing, harvesting & cooking their own food.

6. Woodhouse Pizza

4.7

Exceptional(27)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Greenville

Woodhouse Pizza is open for Takeout or Hangout! Serving a selection of natural wines, cocktails, local beer, small plates, and pizza with ingredients from neighborhood farms.Bring a blanket and relax on the grounds of The Woodhouse Lodge, sit by a fire pit, enjoy the patio - or grab a table in the revived dance hall-turned casual dining room.We can't wait to see you!

Best Pizzerias in Margaretville

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

6 restaurants available nearby

1. The Kaatskeller

2. Lola Pizza

3. Woodstock Pizza Theater

4. Carbonella's Coal Fired Pizza

5. Old School Farm

6. Woodhouse Pizza

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable