Best Seafood Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay
Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility
154 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- GGeoffPhiladelphia County •5 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoBrandon the server, as well as the manager, were fantastic. Ambience and food quality were exceptional.More infoSeneca$$$$• Italian• Downtown•4.6
- BBarbaraGoldSan Diego •115 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoClevel is our favorite restaurant. The food is always superb. The staff is helpful and pleasant. The views are fabulous. I usually order the ahi stack which is absolutely fantastic. The ahi is fresh and the crab, avocado and mango augment both its flavor and texture. The sauce has changed from year to year (There was a time when the ahi was seared but if you requested unseared, the chef complied), but the dish remains my favorite. My other favorite is lobster mac and cheese. It is sinfully delicious, and I am one of the people who can easily devour it in one sitting. The times I haven’t (I am a slow eater) I have finished my “doggie bag” as soon as I arrived home! The rest of the menu is also superb; I have tasted most dishes. But these two are my absolute favorites.More infoC-Level$$$$• Cocktail Bar• Downtown•4.7
- DDeAnnSan Diego •5 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoBeautiful location. Great service & wonderful food. Great experience.More infoCoasterra$$$$• Mexican• Harbor Island•4.7
- AKAlexandraKGreater Boston •5 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 28, 2026Absolutely stunning views, perfect for dinner. Heat lamps on if needed. Staff was great and food was top notch!More infoTom Hams Lighthouse$$$$• Seafood• Downtown•4.7
- HHillaryMinneapolis - St. Paul •2 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 27, 2026Fabulous experience, some of the best, most thoughtful service we’ve gotten. Our server Jake was outstanding, made great suggestions and had a knack for knowing just when to stop by. The dry-aged ribeye was phenomenal, the mushrooms were delicious, the cocktails were on point, and the seasonal macaron was a perfect last bite. The atmosphere is classic without being pretentious, and we appreciated the great music at a volume that allowed us to easily converse without hearing the people around us. We sat in the dining room but took in the gorgeous view from the second floor open air space after dinner. 10/10, would recommend, ask for Jake!More infoBorn & Raised$$$$• Steakhouse• Little Italy•4.7
Discover best Seafood restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay
Discover the delights of seafood dining in the picturesque setting of Shelter Island/San Diego Bay, a prime destination for both locals and visitors seeking exceptional seafood experiences. Nestled along the waterfront, the area boasts a variety of restaurants that specialize in serving fresh, high-quality seafood, prepared with culinary expertise. From traditional dishes that celebrate the local catch to innovative seafood combinations influenced by global flavors, each restaurant offers a unique taste of the ocean's bounty. The dining scene in Shelter Area/San Diego Bay is vibrant and diverse, with eateries providing not only spectacular views of the bay and the San Diego skyline but also a comfortable ambiance perfect for any occasion. Whether you're planning a romantic dinner, a family gathering, or a casual meal with friends, the array of seafood restaurants here caters to all preferences and occasions. Each dining establishment emphasizes freshness and quality, ensuring a memorable meal that highlights the best of what the sea has to offer. This location is a true haven for seafood lovers, where the passion for maritime flavors and the scenic beauty of San Diego Bay come together to create unforgettable dining experiences. Whether you're a seasoned seafood aficionado or just exploring the delightful tastes of the ocean, Shelter Island/San Diego Bay is the perfect spot to indulge in some of the finest seafood meals available.