Best Sicilian Restaurants in Anna Maria Island

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Regions

Anna Maria IslandClearwaterKansas City, KSPunta GordaSarasota / BradentonSt. Petersburg

Neighborhoods

Anna Maria IslandBradenton BeachBrandonClearwaterDowntownLand O' Lakes

Top Rated

CharmingGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunchGreat for fine wines

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Award-winning

MICHELIN

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

19 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Isola Bella Italian Eatery restaurant

1. Isola Bella Italian Eatery

4.7

Exceptional(1416)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Anna Maria Island

Booked 18 times today

Isola Bella Italian Eatery, nestled charmingly on Anna Maria Island in Holmes Beach, offers an unparalleled Mediterranean dining experience. The authenticity of its cuisine shines through in every dish, with diners raving about "the best Italian food we ever had!" The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in their "fresh pasta, homemade sauces, and daily entree specials," making each visit a culinary delight. Guests frequently praise the "authentic flavors" and "perfect portion sizes," which make it stand out as a hidden gem. Whether savoring their delectable pistachio ricotta cake or enjoying their extensive wine list, Isola Bella ensures a memorable meal.

A photo of Casa Santo Stefano restaurant

2. Casa Santo Stefano

4.8

Exceptional(4431)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Ybor City

Booked 53 times today

Benvenuti! Casa Santo Stefano is a Sicilian restaurant from the Gonzmart family, owners of the 1905 Family Of Restaurants. The lunch and dinner menus feature maccheroni (pasta), steaks, seafood, scacciata, salads, soups, desserts and hundreds of Sicilian wines. Curbside takeout is available by calling the main phone number. The rooftop Santo's Drinkeria also is open. Housed in a beautifully re-imagined former 1925 Ybor City macaroni factory, the restaurant is a look back to Sunday suppers, simpler times and shared stories.Dress code: Casa Santo Stefano often is visited for celebrations and special occasion meals, so it is common for our guests to sport formal wear in the dining room. We welcome everyone, but politely ask that men wear sleeves at Casa Santo Stefano.

A photo of Ventura's Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar restaurant

3. Ventura's Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar

4.6

Exceptional(370)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Bradenton Beach

Booked 6 times today

Ventura's Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar, nestled in the charming locale of Longboat Key, offers an unparalleled Dining Bar experience that is both authentic and inviting. Known for its exquisite selection of small vineyard wines and a full bar that complements their homemade Italian cuisine, Ventura's stands out as a true gem. Diners rave about the “excellent wine selection” and the “fantastic Espresso Martini,” served with exceptional service by staff like Terri and Devon. The cozy ambiance, paired with the personalized attention from owners and staff, creates an atmosphere where guests feel right at home, promising an unforgettable dining experience.

A photo of La Norma Ristorante & Pizzeria restaurant

4. La Norma Ristorante & Pizzeria

4.7

Exceptional(973)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Longboat Key

Booked 5 times today

Welcome to La Norma — A Taste of Sicily on Longboat Key.Founded by a first-generation Sicilian family, La Norma brings the warmth and traditions of Southern Italy to Longboat Key. Guests can enjoy handmade pastas, signature pizzas, and a carefully curated selection of Italian and international wines, all crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Gluten-free pasta and pizza options ensure everyone can savor authentic Italian flavors.Dine in the cozy indoor dining room or on the charming outdoor patio, where laughter, conversation, and attentive service make every visit memorable. La Norma also hosts hands-on cooking classes, intimate wine dinners, and private or corporate events, perfect for birthdays, small gatherings, or special celebrations.Every dish is crafted with care and rooted in tradition, letting you taste the heart of Sicily in a warm, inviting atmosphere.

A photo of Bonu' Taverna Italiana restaurant

5. Bonu' Taverna Italiana

4.7

Exceptional(147)

$$$$

• Sicilian • St. Petersburg

Booked 34 times today

At Bonu’ Taverna, we believe that one of the greatest sources of joy is what happens around the dinner table.

A photo of BellaBrava St.Pete restaurant

6. BellaBrava St.Pete

4.8

Exceptional(1085)

$$$$

• Sicilian • St. Petersburg

Booked 47 times today

BellaBrava New World Trattoria was born in 2005 in Downtown Saint Petersburg. Over the years since, BellaBrava has been voted Best Restaurant in Saint Petersburg, Best Italian, and is a perennial Guest favorite on Beach Drive.Less formal than a ristorante, our service is casual, our prices remain reasonable and our emphasis is on a steady clientele rather than haute cuisine. Old World flavors mingle with New World flair. From seafood to traditional pasta, pizzas, and more, we are positive everyone will find something delicious to savor.BellaBrava’s unique Woodstone™ ovens cook delicious pizzas and a guest favorite, the Crostata. Our ingredients are fresh, often locally sourced, and evoke the flavors of Tuscany and other delicious cuisines from Italy. With friendly, competent staff, BellaBrava aims to be your casual dining spot.

A photo of Trattoria Bella Napoli restaurant

7. Trattoria Bella Napoli

4.7

Exceptional(331)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Downtown

Booked 28 times today

## Trattoria Bella Napoli: A Taste of Italy in the Heart of SarasotaBest Authentic Italian and Neapolitan Pizza in Sarasota , traditional wood-fired oven, using imported Italian ingredients. Located in the heart of downtown Sarasota, Trattoria Bella Napoli offers a true Italian dining experience with handmade pizzas, fresh pasta, and a warm atmosphere.2 Place at the World Neapolitan Pizza Championship in Las Vegas 2024.Best Pizza Sarasota Herald Tribune 2025.

8. Cafe Amici

4.6

Exceptional(1154)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Sarasota

Booked 9 times today

Cafe Amici in Sarasota is a beacon of authentic Mediterranean cuisine, offering an exceptional dining experience since 1996. The restaurant's menu is a delightful journey through the flavors of Puglia, Veneto, Tuscany, and beyond. Diners rave about the "delicious pastas and wine," praising the authenticity and freshness of the dishes. Each visit is enhanced by friendly, knowledgeable service, with owner Massimo often greeting guests warmly. The "outstanding" meals, coupled with a vibrant atmosphere and a world-class wine selection, make Cafe Amici a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine taste of the Mediterranean in the heart of Sarasota.

9. BellaBrava Tampa

4.5

Awesome(769)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Tampa

Booked 13 times today

BellaBrava New World Trattoria was born in 2005 in Downtown Saint Petersburg. Over the years since, BellaBrava has been voted Best Restaurant in Saint Petersburg, Best Italian, and is a perennial Guest favorite on Beach Drive.Now open in Midtown Tampa, BellaBrava Tampa brings the same menu and outstanding service we are proud of to Tampa. Enjoy great Italian wines and cocktails, New World Trattoria cuisine, and consistently excellent service.In the heart of Midtown Tampa, we’re the perfect spot for a great lunch while shopping, or an intimate dinner with friends and family.

A photo of Soul Sicilian Fusion restaurant

10. Soul Sicilian Fusion

4.6

Exceptional(606)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Clearwater

Booked 4 times today

Soul Sicilian Fusion, nestled in the heart of Clearwater, Florida, serves up an impeccable Seafood experience with a Sicilian twist. Renowned for its authentic flavors, the restaurant's dedication to "high quality local produce and fresh fish" is evident in every dish. Chef Nello, with roots in Catania, Sicily, masterfully combines traditional recipes with local freshness, creating a seafood menu that is nothing short of spectacular. One delighted diner exclaimed, "The grilled octopus was tender and delicious," while another raved about the "very large and fresh portion of fish." Soul Sicilian Fusion promises a Seafood dining experience that's both authentic and unforgettable.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Sicilian Cuisine

Anna Maria Island

Apollo Beach
Bellair Bluffs
St. Pete Beach
Safety Harbor
Englewood
Dade City
Tampa
Lake Alfred
Bradenton Beach
Spring Hill
Gulf Gate Estates
Brooksville
Lakewood Ranch
Venice
Longboat Key
Seminole
Sarasota
Venice Gardens
Temple Terrace
Auburndale