20 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Mahwah

20 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Pizzeria Mandara

4.7

Exceptional(687)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Wyckoff

Booked 17 times today

We were there for lunch -sandwiches were delicious-the ciabatta bread is excellent! The service was friendly, professional & appropriate-not invasive-just attentive enough.

A photo of Donatella's Ristorante restaurant

2. Donatella's Ristorante

4.4

Awesome(1132)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Closter

Booked 9 times today

Best restaurant in the area! We got the baked clams, stuffed hot peppers, to start and they were all 10/10. Me and my fiancee got the pappardelle , bone in ribeye steak special, and it was perfection! I had the tiramisu for dessert and it was the best. I can't wait to go back! Super high-end italian place in New Jersey. You'll see Don at the restaurant from time to time. The staff members are phenomenal to deal with very friendly and super nice the food is very Italian authentic al dente with all their pasta. 10/10 would totally come back there again just for the pasta. Bravo

3. Bottagra

4.8

Exceptional(1502)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Hawthorne

Booked 20 times today

Excellent experience and the place is decorated beautifully !!!

4. Forte Ristorante

4.6

Exceptional(284)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Hackensack

Booked 4 times today

The bartender, Erica, is so personable and welcoming! My nephew said the drink she made him was the best he has ever had! That is the type of service that I was hoping for my mom’s 82nd birthday gathering. Michael, our waiter, was so nice and a great server. The place is beautiful and service is even better. My mom was so happy with it and we definitely will be back.

A photo of Rosario's Trattoria restaurant

5. Rosario's Trattoria

4.8

Exceptional(285)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Midland Park

Booked 3 times today

First time there and we'll be back. Very good food, big portions and reasonably priced plus service was friendly and attentive.

6. The Highlawn

4.6

Exceptional(1761)

$$$$

• Sicilian • West Orange

Booked 28 times today

Amazing service, great views and top notch food!!!

7. Basso by PXK

4.8

Exceptional(2002)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Chappaqua

Booked 42 times today

We celebrated my son’s birthday. The food, service and pace of the pots and pans brunch was excellent.

8. Osteria Italiana

4.6

Exceptional(12)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Garfield

Booked 5 times today

Great experience. The food was delicious and the staff professional.

9. Tramonto

4.8

Exceptional(736)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Pleasantville

Booked 16 times today

Every single thing about this restaurant is FANTASTIC! The food, the ambience, the service etc! They made us feel like regulars! They had their eyes on every patron while still allowing us to dine in privacy. They should be packed every night!

10. Francesco's

4.9

Exceptional(120)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Totowa

Booked 3 times today

I don’t usually write reviews, however, I felt the food and the atmosphere and the help was exceptional and worth taking my time out to write this. We will be back!

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Mahwah

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

20 restaurants available nearby

1. Pizzeria Mandara

2. Donatella's Ristorante

3. Bottagra

4. Forte Ristorante

5. Rosario's Trattoria

6. The Highlawn

7. Basso by PXK

8. Osteria Italiana

9. Tramonto

10. Francesco's

Explore OpenTable