16 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Turtle Bay

A photo of Rosemary's Midtown restaurant

1. Rosemary's Midtown

4.6

Exceptional(120)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Midtown East

Booked 35 times today

Rosemary’s Midtown is a neighborhood Italian restaurant located on the corner of Third Avenue & 50th Street. A short walk from the UN, Rockefeller Center, & Midtown offices, it’s a warm & welcoming spot for lunch breaks, after-work cocktails, pre-theater dinners, & weekend brunches.Inspired by the Italian countryside & powered by seasonal ingredients, our menu features house made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, fresh salads, & comforting classics. Favorites include the Rigatoni Arrabbiata, Pappardelle Verde, Steak Tagliata, along with signature pizzas like the Soppressata with hot honey & Mushroom & Sausage. Lighter options like the Chopped Salad ‘Siciliana’ & Lani’s Market Greens make it easy to eat well, any time of day. Whether you’re dining inside our airy main dining room, tucked away in the private dining room, or enjoying the energy of Midtown on our outdoor patio, Rosemary’s offers a true taste of Italy in the heart of Manhattan.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Uptown restaurant

2. Piccola Cucina Uptown

4.8

Exceptional(2696)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Upper East Side

Booked 89 times today

Piccola Cucina Uptown, nestled in the vibrant Upper East Side of New York, offers a superb journey into Contemporary Italian cuisine. This charming gem exudes warmth and authenticity, setting the stage for an unparalleled dining experience. Guests rave about its "impeccable service" and the "incredible" freshness and flavor of their dishes, particularly the handmade pastas and Sicilian specialties. The restaurant's attention to detail is evident, from the expertly crafted tiramisu to the delightful table-side presentations. As one reviewer enthusiastically shared, "It's a gem I’ll definitely return to!" Whether for a cozy dinner or lively gathering, Piccola Cucina Uptown promises an unforgettable culinary adventure.

A photo of Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC restaurant

3. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(32489)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 347 times today

Carmine's - 44th Street in NYC's vibrant Theater District is a gem for Contemporary Italian cuisine that truly stands out. The restaurant's dedication to delivering generous family-style portions echoes the warmth of an Italian American wedding feast, making every visit feel like a "Sunday afternoon at Grandma's." With a menu brimming with made-to-order pasta, succulent seafood, and exquisite homemade desserts, diners are in for a treat. The glowing reviews speak volumes with remarks like "food was truly amazing" and "service was fast and attentive." Carmine's is not just a meal; it's a delightful culinary experience worth savoring.

4. Sicily

4.5

Awesome(840)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 30 times today

Located on Restaurant Row in the heart of Manhattan in the Hell’s Kitchen neighborhood and Theater District, Sicily Osteria is a dining destination that appeals to local residents and office workers, as well as Broadway theatergoers. The restaurant offers several dining experiences, from its more formal main dining room that exudes a rustic elegance enhanced by vintage green walls, exposed brick, custom tiled floor and white tablecloths. It's front dining room features an expansive bar, perfect for casual dining; plus, several bistro-style tables; and in the far back, a spacious, naturally lit, enclosed patio garden and atrium transports guests to a lush garden oasis.

A photo of Empire Steak House - Midtown East restaurant

5. Empire Steak House - Midtown East

4.7

Exceptional(1363)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Midtown East

Booked 14 times today

Empire Steak House - East, nestled in Midtown East, New York, is not just a haven for steak lovers but also a gem for seafood enthusiasts. Revered for its "delicious and fresh" lobsters and renowned seafood offerings, the restaurant ensures that diners experience the pinnacle of quality and authenticity in each bite. The seafood here is highlighted by rave reviews stating "lump crabmeat cocktail with large lumps of crabmeat" as a standout dish. The impeccable service and inviting ambiance further enhance this culinary journey, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking an exquisite seafood dining experience in the heart of New York.

6. Serafina 38th

4.5

Awesome(567)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Murray Hill

Booked 31 times today

Serafina 38th in Murray Hill, New York, is a standout destination for authentic Pizza Bar cuisine, priding itself on sourcing the finest ingredients from around the globe. This commitment to quality shines through in every bite, making each pizza an "amazing" experience that diners rave about. Guests consistently highlight the "excellent food" and "fantastic service," creating an inviting atmosphere that feels both lively and welcoming. The Margherita pizza, a crowd favorite, captures the essence of traditional Italian flavors, making it a must-try for pizza enthusiasts. With its vibrant ambiance and delicious offerings, Serafina 38th is truly a neighborhood gem.

7. San Pietro

4.7

Exceptional(625)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Midtown East

Booked 7 times today

Welcome to the newly renovated San Pietro. We are proud to reopen with a refined space and an updated menu that showcases authentic Italian cuisine.Rooted in the philosophy of “Nourishing Body and Soul,” our dishes honor our Salerno heritage, with over 85% of ingredients sourced directly from Italy for true, unforgettable flavor.Conveniently located near Fifth Avenue, Broadway, and MoMA, we welcome both returning guests and new clientele for business dining, family gatherings, and special occasions. Private events are available in our new dining room, and special requests can be arranged in advance.Dress Code: Smart Casual.

A photo of Olio e Più - Bryant Park restaurant

8. Olio e Più - Bryant Park

4.4

Awesome(349)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Midtown

Booked 70 times today

Located just steps from Bryant Park, the second OLIO E PIÙ outpost in New York offers a warm and welcoming escape in the heart of Manhattan. Surrounded by the energy of Fifth Avenue and Midtown’s timeless charm, it brings Italian tradition and a true sense of Mediterranean liveliness to one of the city’s most iconic neighborhoods.As an authentic trattoria, its cuisine celebrates classic Italian dishes crafted with seasonal ingredients and genuine hospitality. Whether guests are unwinding after a day of shopping, enjoying a weekend stroll through the park, or gathering for a relaxed yet refined meal after work, OLIO E PIÙ offers a true Italian retreat in the heart of the city.Here, the spirit of La Dolce Vita comes to life, evoking the golden age of Italian elegance, where good company, fine wine, and timeless flavors meet amidst the rhythm of New York. Every visit is a celebration of delicious food, great wine, and memorable conversation.*Please note kitchen hours may differ.

A photo of Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant restaurant

9. Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(2928)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 6 times today

Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant in the heart of New York's Theater District is a true gem for Seafood aficionados. Known for its authentic Italian flavors, the restaurant serves exquisite Seafood dishes that leave diners raving. One standout dish, the seafood linguini, is praised for being "amazing," with perfectly cooked seafood that complements the homemade pasta beautifully. Guests also adore the special black pasta with fra diavolo seafood, described as "spot on with great service." The intimate ambiance, coupled with attentive staff, ensures a memorable dining experience. Whether you're pre-theater or just in the mood for exceptional Seafood, Chazz Palminteri is a must-visit.

A photo of Bocca Di Bacco (Theatre District - 45th St.) restaurant

10. Bocca Di Bacco (Theatre District - 45th St.)

4.5

Awesome(3455)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 13 times today

Bocca Di Bacco in the Theater District of New York is a haven for lovers of authentic Sicilian cuisine. This charming spot, formerly known as Film Center Cafe, impresses with a dynamic menu featuring traditional dishes crafted from the healthiest, locally-sourced ingredients. Guests rave about the "delicious food and excellent service," highlighting standout dishes such as the seafood pasta and grilled octopus. The restaurant's enchanting ambiance, complete with live music and candlelit tables, creates an inviting atmosphere perfect for pre-theater dining. With a commitment to "Farm to Table" philosophy and an extensive selection of Italian wines, Bocca Di Bacco offers a genuine taste of Southern Italy that keeps diners coming back.

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Turtle Bay

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

16 restaurants available nearby

1. Rosemary's Midtown

2. Piccola Cucina Uptown

3. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

4. Sicily

5. Empire Steak House - Midtown East

6. Serafina 38th

7. San Pietro

8. Olio e Più - Bryant Park

9. Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant

10. Bocca Di Bacco (Theatre District - 45th St.)

Explore OpenTable