Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. Maine

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Peaks Island

Price
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

10 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Benny's restaurant
1. Benny's
4.7
Exceptional(74)
$$$$
• Italian • Portland
Booked 10 times today
Benny's is a Philly-inspired, Italian-American restaurant in Portland's Arts District, from the team behind Ramona's Sandwich Shop. Enjoy a signature cocktail at our 14-seat bar, or settle down at a table for a night of classic dishes such as Meatballs, Linguine and Clams, Chicken Parmesan, or Pretzel Garlic Knots. Younger guests can enjoy our unique take on a Shirley Temple while enjoying Mozzarella Sticks and Pasta. Our dining room is fit for date nights and celebratory evenings. Benny’s is all about balance—nostalgic, comforting dishes made with the best ingredients and some modern twists for creative fun.
A photo of The Front Room restaurant
2. The Front Room
4.5
Awesome(544)
$$$$
• American • Portland
Booked 15 times today
Due to volume we are unable to accept reservations for Brunch. Tables are available on a walk-in basis. Reservations are available for Dinner. For parties over 6, please call 773-3366 during business hours to make reservations.Nestled atop Portland’s Munjoy Hill neighborhood, The Front Room, offers dishes & drinks with comfort in mind. A local Brunch destination, enjoy plates such as house-made Corned Beef Hash, Veggie Gnocchi, & Eggs Benedict. Pancakes & French Toast are always a go to. Serving a variety of Mimosas & Bloody Marys, local coffee & teas. Dinner at TFR is relaxed & pleasurable. Plates are made with local components & thoughtful recipes. Enjoy the Casco Bay Scallops, Braised Shortrib, Mushroom Toast, or neighborhood favorite Roasted Pork Loin with JJ's famous bacon jam. Serving a variety of local beer, wine, and cocktails to suit every taste- Come get Happy 4-6 !
A photo of REGARDS restaurant
3. REGARDS
4.4
Awesome(399)
$$$$
• Seafood • Portland
Booked 9 times today
Bringing some LA vibes to the northeast. REGARDS draws inspiration from the diverse food culture of Los Angeles. We highlight flavor profiles from Japan and Mexico with the freshest of Maine produce and products. The menu at REGARDS has bright, zippy ceviches and crudos, rich tamales, plump Argentinian shrimp tacos, along with mezcal cured hamachi collars, crab rice and grilled cabbage with caesar. Clarified lime margaritas with eucalyptus or our gin and sotol martinis with hibiscus pair with our adventurous menu. We pour natural wine and have a large selection of curated mezcals and tequilas.A place for us and for you. Might not make sense, but it sure is delicious. Across the street from Reny's. Nearby Maine College of Art, Portland Stage Company, State Theatre, Empire Comedy Club and Blue Jazz Club. **The 50 Best New Restaurants of 2022, Bon Appetit****Plate Magazine Chef's To Watch, 2023****Star Chef New England, 2023**
A photo of Magnus on Water restaurant
4. Magnus on Water
5.0
Exceptional(427)
$$$$
• Comfort Food • Biddeford
Booked 15 times today
Magnus on Water is a cocktail bar and restaurant in Biddeford, Maine, where Peruvian-inspired comfort food from Chef Rafael Zimmerman meets an award-winning beverage program led by Bar Director Brian “Cat” Catapang. Our cocktail program has been recognized with a Pinnacle Pin, one of the industry’s highest honors, celebrating excellence in craft, creativity, and hospitality.Our menu and drinks change with the seasons, highlighting Maine’s farmers, foragers, and fishermen who share our commitment to sustainability and respect for the natural world. The space is polished yet intimate — a place to linger over beautiful food, conversation, and cocktails. In the warmer months, our garden patio with fire pits extends that same welcoming spirit outdoors. Magnus also offers a private dining room for gatherings and full or partial event rentals.
A photo of Pomelia restaurant
5. Pomelia
4.8
Exceptional(331)
$$$$
• Italian • Brunswick
Booked 22 times today
Welcome to Pomelia, where we bring the authentic flavors of Sicily to your table with a menu inspired by traditional recipes and rich culinary heritage. From delicious pastas and focaccia-style pizzas to iconic Sicilian street food, every dish is prepared with the freshest ingredients and a passion for flavor and warm hospitality.We’re passionate about more than just food—we love sharing the stories and traditions that make Sicilian cuisine special. At Pomelia, every meal celebrates flavor, culture, and connection, served with warmth and a smile.Step into our colorful, retro-modern restaurant and experience a space designed for joy and connection. Whether you’re visiting for a casual lunch, a family dinner, or a special night out, our lively decor and friendly vibe make Pomelia the perfect destination for any occasion.
A photo of The Puddle Dock restaurant
6. The Puddle Dock
4.8
Exceptional(1254)
$$$$
• American • Portsmouth
Booked 21 times today
The Puddle Dock is your go-to spot for comfort food. It's a place where you can savor classic American and English favorites, reimagined with modern twists. Reviewers rave about the 'exceptional service,' 'delicious food,' and 'warm & beautiful ambiance'. Dishes like Yorkshire Pudding, Pan-Roasted Duck Breast, and signature Hoe Cake are loved by many. Plus, who can resist their Cinnamon Rum Breading, Dark Chocolate Pudding, and Posset desserts? The Puddle Dock is a cozy, colonial-chic spot where you can relax and enjoy a memorable meal.
A photo of Sea Dog Brewing Co. - So. Portland restaurant
7. Sea Dog Brewing Co. - So. Portland
4.3
Awesome(40)
$$$$
• Pub • Portland
Booked 3 times today
Using only the most superior ingredients in their beer and plates, Sea Dog Brewing Company in South Portland serves up innovative pub fare with an original touch. All beer sold at Sea Dog Brewing Company are hand-crafted, as is the American pub cuisine, adding to the restaurant's authenticity. The restaurant offers ample seating for most party sizes, and boasts a private function room available to reserve for group gatherings. Sea Dog Brewing Company offers a selection of pub comfort favorites like Maine lobster bisque with huge chunks of lobster meat, steak tip poutine, and plenty of shareable appetizers. In addition, the menu features other popular dishes like fish and chips and blackened haddock tacos, as well as vegetarian and gluten free options.The friendly staff at Sea Dog Brewing on Western Avenue in South Portland would love to take care of you while you await your flight at PWM, on your lunch break from work, or for weekend brunch with family and friends!
A photo of The Oxford House Inn restaurant
8. The Oxford House Inn
4.7
Exceptional(1216)
$$$$
• American • Fryeburg
Booked 3 times today
The Oxford House Inn & Restaurant, a Western Maine Bed and Breakfast and Full Service Inn, offers visitors to the Mt. Washington Valley and Maine's Western Lakes Region four beautifully appointed guest rooms, a sixty seat restaurant and granite-walled pub. Built in 1913 by renowned architect John Calvin Stevens, the stately Mission style architecture, stunning sunset mountain views, exceptional food and warm New England hospitality have established The Oxford House Inn as a dining and lodging destination.
A photo of Farm Bar & Grill - Dover restaurant
9. Farm Bar & Grill - Dover
4.6
Exceptional(97)
$$$$
• Comfort Food • Dover
Booked 9 times today
The Farm Bar & Grill in Dover, New Hampshire is a place where people of all ages come to have great food with friends and family. The Farm Bar & Grille is more than a restaurant, its an experience. Created by two brothers and their cousin, who left the corporate world to follow their dream of owning a restaurant. We welcome you and invite you to enjoy The Farm's delicious homemade fresh food, signature cocktails and lively atmosphere. OUTDOOR DINING IS FIRST COME FIRST SERVE- NO RESERVATIONS Menu items can vary
A photo of The Rail at La Stazione restaurant
10. The Rail at La Stazione
4.5
Awesome(96)
$$$$
• Italian • Dover
Booked 5 times today
Elevate your evening at The Rail at La Stazione! Join us for a taste of sophistication and culinary innovation. Our meticulously crafted menu promises to redefine your dining expectations. At The Rail we offer an extensive menu for take out or delivery. La Stazione is our Dine In restaurant offering delicious food and drink. Enjoy a meal with us.We look forward to serving you.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2026 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo