Best Cozy Restaurants in Sheridan, Indiana

We came to celebrate my husband’s birthday. Everything was exceptional.

My wife and I were a little early for our 5:00 seating at Nyla's. However, we were seated right away and our waitress, Sam, provided the menus and took our drink orders. We both decided to order from the early bird menu which is good Monday through Thursday until 6:00. The early bird menu offers a 3 course meal for only $25, which is a great value! My wife orders the wedge salad for her first course and I had the mushroom soup. Both were excellent! For our main course we both decided on the f4 piece fried chicken with mashed potatoes. The chicken was perfect, not greasy at all and the white meat was moist not dry as sometimes happens at other restaurants. For our final course, Nyla's offers New York style cheese cake with a choice of 4 toppings. I had Carmel and my wife opted for strawberry compote. Again, the result was excellent and the small individual servings were the perfect size. All and all, our dinner at Nyla's was great and at $25 GREAT value. I highly recommend this fine restaurant.

We did an anniversary lunch on May 6, and the whole staff was amazing. Food was great, they made us feel special for celebrating with them. We will definitely be back for an anniversary lunch/dinner.

Perfect celabratory dinner! Cuisine was unique and delicious. Our server was knowlegible, honest and fun! Ambiance as elegant as the food. A little noisy while the prom crowd was dining, but they were excited to be there too. Cannot wait to return!!!

Good hand held's, good vibe and good service. The bonus was that the beer was on special.