Best Cozy Restaurants in Bayshore Gardens, Tampa / Central Florida West

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Cuisine

AmericanItalianSteakhouseSeafoodFrenchIndian

Regions

Anna Maria IslandClearwaterSarasota / BradentonSt. PetersburgTampa

Neighborhoods

Anna Maria IslandBellair BluffsBradentonBrandonClearwaterClearwater Beach

Top Rated

CharmingDog-friendlyFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasions

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Award-winning

MICHELIN

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

122 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Scarpino's Classic Italian restaurant

1. Scarpino's Classic Italian

4.5

Awesome(417)

$$$$

• Italian • South Bradenton

Booked 7 times today

Scarpino’s Classic Italian isn’t just dining — it’s authentic Italian tradition, crafted with passion.Locally owned and rooted in family hospitality, Scarpino’s brings the flavors of Italy to Bradenton & Sarasota with recipes made from scratch and served with warmth. Our team includes a master Pizzaiolo from Italy with over 25 years of pizza-making expertise, ensuring every hand-tossed pie is true to its heritage.Everyone is welcomed with complimentary garlic knots before enjoying scratch-made pastas, hand-tossed pizzas, savory entrées, and indulgent desserts — all crafted from the freshest ingredients.Perfect for family dinners, romantic date nights, or gatherings with friends, our cozy dining room and attentive service create an atmosphere where every guest feels like part of the family. Pair your meal with a glass of wine or a handcrafted cocktail, and savor the flavors of Italy right here in Sarasota/Bradenton.

2. Taverna Toscana

4.7

Exceptional(469)

$$$$

• Italian • Bradenton

Booked 29 times today

In downtown Bradenton, Florida, Taverna Toscana is led by the renowned Chef Fabio Viviani, offering an unparalleled Tuscan Italian dining experience. Our steakhouse blends Tuscan charm with modern sophistication, presenting an exquisite menu that transports you to the heart of Italy. The warm ambiance and handcrafted decor complement the authentic Italian flavors and the finest steaks, curated by Chef Viviani, a celebrated figure known for his culinary prowess and appearances on Bravo's "Top Chef." This venture, in partnership with Bradenton's entrepreneur Steve Herrig, symbolizes a commitment to culinary excellence and the revitalization of downtown Bradenton. At Taverna Toscana, we celebrate the shared essence of Tuscany and Florida: warm sun, wonderful people, and a passion for fresh, sublime food. Our indoor/outdoor dining welcomes everyone-from families and foodies to CEOs and couples-with aged steaks, homemade pasta, and crafted drinks in an inviting atmosphere that draws inspiration from Italy itself. Taverna Toscana isn't just a dining destination; it's a bold statement of culinary delight, offering a slice of Italy in Florida's friendliest city. Join us to experience the joy of Italian dining, where every visit promises an indulgent journey of taste and authenticity.

A photo of The Rosemary & Thyme restaurant

3. The Rosemary & Thyme

4.7

Exceptional(5343)

$$$$

• American • Sarasota

Welcome to Rosemary & Thyme! Downtown Sarasota American Bistro serving traditional and contemporary dishes with an emphasis on healthy options. Savor made-from-scratch selections for breakfast, lunch and dinner prepared with fresh ingredients from regional farms.

4. Tiramisu

4.8

Exceptional(1041)

$$$$

• Italian • South Bradenton

Booked 17 times today

Owners, Luca and Monica, invite their patrons into Tiramisu of Bradenton as if welcoming them into their own home to enjoy these delicious, family recipes.Tiramisu’s atmosphere is intimate and casual but ensures that you will have friendly, professional service and well-seasoned, authentic Italian dishes served with love upon every visit. Family owned fine Italian dining in the heart of Bradenton. Classic dishes, specialty homemade pasta, great wine and intimate atmosphere at affordable prices.

5. My Mamma

4.4

Awesome(138)

$$$$

• Italian • Sarasota

Booked 17 times today

Come for the food, stay for the mood—this is Italy, the MYMAMMA way.At MYMAMMA, we bring the warmth of an Italian home straight to your table. Inspired by the flavors of southern Italy and family traditions, our restaurant offers a cozy, welcoming space where every detail—from the rustic decor to the smell of freshly baked focaccia—feels like a hug from Nonna.Enjoy comforting classics like Eggplant Parmigiana, Roman Focaccia (Pinsa Romana), and seafood pasta, all made with high-quality ingredients and a touch of love. Whether you're here for a quick bite or a long, relaxed dinner with friends and family, MYMAMMA is the place to savor authentic Italian moments in a relaxed, friendly atmosphere.

A photo of Euphemia Haye Restaurant & The Haye Loft restaurant

6. Euphemia Haye Restaurant & The Haye Loft

4.6

Exceptional(324)

$$$$

• American • Longboat Key

Booked 22 times today

Chef Raymond & D’Arcy Arpke followed their passion for fine food and purchased Euphemia Haye, a tiny 28-seat restaurant on Longboat Key, in 1980. In the forty years since, they have expanded the restaurant, added the Haye Loft, and built a family of staff. Most impressively, their care for our guests and the dining experience has never waned. We invite you to come dine with us and “let go.” Enjoy a glass of wine and feast on our award-winning global and American food while you look out onto our beautiful tropical grounds.

7. Boca - Sarasota

4.4

Awesome(1876)

$$$$

• Contemporary American • Sarasota

Booked 22 times today

Boca - Sarasota is cozy due to its inviting ambiance. With reviews raving about the 'great vibe' and 'wonderful ambience,' it's clear the restaurant creates a comfortable and relaxed atmosphere. The décor is rustic, adding to the cozy feel, and the open kitchen provides a view that adds to the intimacy. It's a place you'd want to sit back and enjoy a meal in the midst of a relaxed environment.

A photo of The Café on St.Armands restaurant

8. The Café on St.Armands

4.6

Exceptional(265)

$$$$

• Mediterranean • Sarasota

Booked 15 times today

Café on St. Armands, Mediterranean Soul in the Heart of Sarasota. Inspired by our founders' vision of bringing a taste of Europe to Sarasota's shores, our menu now showcases a rich Mediterranean influence, seamlessly woven through every dish and drink. Small plates and shareable bites, with bold Southern European and Middle Eastern flavors, are served in a hip space where all are welcome. Whether you’re grabbing coffee and pastries at our new gourmet coffee bar...catching up over cocktails at The Wet Bar...or enjoying a relaxed, vibrant meal with friends...Café is the perfect atmosphere for celebrating every moment. With versatile spaces for gathering, carry-out premium liquors and wines, bespoke picnic baskets, and more, Café on St. Armands is more than a restaurant. It’s Sarasota’s newest destination for good vibes and delicious meals. Oysters Rock Hospitality proudly serves Five Star Fun hospitality at our seven Sarasota-Bradenton area restaurants.

9. Rose & Ivy

4.4

Awesome(677)

$$$$

• Asian • Sarasota

Rose & Ivy, located in the beautiful two-story, vine-covered historic I.R Burns and H.H. Bell Building right next to the Sarasota Opera House in the heart of Downtown Sarasota. Featuring eclectic Pan-Asian cuisine, with a focus on sushi, sizzling steak, exotic dim sum, a superb beverage program, plus a curated atmosphere like nothing in Sarasota.The space is a multi-faceted property with large front and courtyard patios with lots of fans for Florida weather, an interior dining room, and an upstairs speakeasy-style piano bar.

10. Indigenous

4.8

Exceptional(1445)

$$$$

• American • Sarasota

Booked 29 times today

Opened in 2011, Indigenous has earned a reputation for being an inspirational and educational restaurant. For years, Indigenous has been known as one of America’s top restaurants, renowned for its passion for food, the community, and the planet. Indigenous’ menu of seasonal American cuisine changes progressively throughout the year based on peak ingredient availability. With a focus on sustainable seafood and the importance of aquaculture, we work closely with local fisherman, artisans, and farmers to maintain the highest quality. At Indigenous, we are always working our best to create a better food system. Co-Owner Chef Steve Phelps has been a James Beard Foundation Semi Finalist for Best Chef South in 2014 & 2015, an Ambassador for Monterey Bay Aquarium Seafood Watch Blue Ribbon Task Force, and founder of the Seafood Intelligence Group.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

B
Brooke
Miami - Dade •4 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
We had an amazing time. The garlic knots were amazing and the calamari with lemon caper sauce to die for. The fettuccine Alfredo was sooooo good and the pizza perfect! Highly recommended
More info
Scarpino's Classic Italian$$$$• Italian• South Bradenton
•
4.5
A
AngieGold
Detroit / Eastern Michigan •21 reviews
4.0
Dined 4 days ago
This place has excellent salmon! Their cocktails are good too.
More info
Boca - Sarasota$$$$• Contemporary American• Sarasota
•
4.4
P
Paul
Tampa / Central Florida West •1 review
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Best Mother’s Day Brunch we have ever been to. All the food was presented and tasted amazing.
More info
Taverna Toscana$$$$• Italian• Bradenton
•
4.7
L
linda
Denver / Colorado •1 review
5.0
Dined on Apr 28, 2026
Shayna our server was attentive, knowledgeable, and engaged. The setting is warm and wonderful. The restaurant remembered that this was a special birthday and made the evening special for us. The food was outstanding! We can not wait to go back again soon!
More info
The Rosemary & Thyme$$$$• American• Sarasota
•
4.7
M
Maryann
Tampa / Central Florida West •11 reviews
4.0
Dined on Apr 22, 2026
Food was very good, good size portions that could be shared. Cute little Italian place with feeling of cozy. Service was very good!
More info
My Mamma$$$$• Italian• Sarasota
•
4.4

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Cozy

Bayshore Gardens

Clearwater
Apollo Beach
Palm Harbor
Bradenton Beach
Lakeland
Port Richey
Pinellas Park
Land O' Lakes
Gibsonton
Dade City
Dunedin
Anna Maria Island
Bradenton
Tarpon Springs
Englewood
Sebring
Temple Terrace
St. Pete Beach
Madeira Beach
Indian Rocks Beach