Best Restaurants with a Tasting Menu in Nantucket

What a find! Such a classic dining experience. All staff were inviting & Vivian was a master service person. Food presentation & taste was spectacular!

Creative, super fresh, and delicious tasting menu! We couldn’t decide which course we enjoyed the best, but major kudos on the scallop crudo and poached lobster dishes. The staff and owners are super knowledgeable and engaging. My partner said the wine list was most unique and tried a few that blew him away. Thanks for making this milestone celebration so memorable!

We had a reservation just because it was our first time here. Heard great things about it. Service was great, food was great, the appetizer was ok, pretzel over some cold cheese. 1st Pretzel was cooked to dark and was tough to chew they got us another 1 should’ve lighter. But was manageable. Drinks were awesome. Food was great . Deserts were great as well. Then went outside to listen to music and sit by the fire pit and sit on the relaxing chairs. Should have blankets to use with the same logo as the chairs. Great resale value. But makes the cold nights more enjoyable. Just get all cotton blankets.. But will be back again. John mcgrale

We had a great time! Professional service but welcoming and friendly. Really cozy beautiful dining room. Really good, local, interesting food!

If I could give 10 stars I would! Service, menu and vibes are always perfect. We were so happy to be able to dine during the seasonal closing weekend and take advantage of the OH Classics pairing menu. It was delicious! We're already counting down until spring. We hope the entire OH staff enjoys much needed rest and time off during the off season. Thank you always!