Best Restaurants for Afternoon Tea in Shelter Island

I enjoy going to different kinds of restaurants throughout the year. Nevertheless, for dinner on my birthday, I always like to go out to Artisan with my wife. The food and service are always great, the vibe is lively but not noisy, and it’s a comfortable experience on a day important to me. Much to like about this place!

This was my first time at Max Downtown and I’ll definitely be back!! The food was amazing and the service was even better. They were SO accommodating with a gluten sensitivity and even have GF rolls which was a nice surprise :) Our waitress and the manager went above and beyond to make a birthday special. Thank you Max team!

What a treat to be here, I’ve always had a great experience. Having drinks outside by the fire pit on a cool fall night, then going to a great dinner, then strolling to the Awesome side door jazz club - which always has the most extraordinary talent is really beyond compare for our quiet little town. Then consider it began in the 1850’s, this sense of hospitality and adventure combine. I just love this place.

What an incredible experience!! A must! I felt like I was in a movie having a little tea party! I believe it’s the owner served us. She’s incredible…. Beautiful memory I had with my family.