City Island Restaurants
Make a free reservation
Available for late dinner now in New York City
OpenTable Icons
Book this year’s award-winners, hot newcomers, and hard-to-get tables.
Book this year’s award-winners, hot newcomers, and hard-to-get tables.
Top restaurants this week
Explore what's popular with other diners with these lists, updated weekly.
Explore what's popular with other diners with these lists, updated weekly.
Top booked
Top viewed
Find the right table in City Island
Find the right table in City Island
Let OpenTable find the best spots for you.
Powered by AI
New restaurants to OpenTable in New York City
Check out diners' favorite restaurants in City Island
Updated on
Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.
Sea Shore Restaurant & Marina
$$$$•Seafood•4.6(511)Enjoy our upscale comfortable seafaring settings. Savor our fresh seafood specialties, sushi bar, and exceptional wine list. An array of cocktails, mixed drinks and tropical frozen delights await you in our fabulous lounge and outdoor deck Bar.Vistamar Restaurant & Lounge
$$$$•Latin American•4.5(488)looking for a cozy dinner or a lively night out, Vistamar Restaurant & Lounge on City Island is your destination. This Latin-fusion gem offers a vibrant atmosphere and stunning waterfront views, featuring a menu that highlights the freshest seafood and Latin American flavors. Indulge in a variety of dishes, from succulent paella and grilled octopus to classic churrasco and mofongo, with plenty of vegetarian options available. The intimate setting is perfect for a romantic dinner or a fun gathering with friends, complemented by attentive service. Enjoy the outdoor patio with breathtaking harbor views, and immerse yourself in the cultural experience with live music and Broadway-style shows. At Vistamar, every visit is more than just a meal; it's a celebration of flavor and entertainment that creates lasting memories. Come and discover your culinary oasis today!
See what locals rave about in City Island
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- FFrancesGoldNew York City •17 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoExcellent, I already rated you on Open Table & posted pictures... I forgot to hit to send to Sea Shore, City Island. Hopefully, you will be able to see it...We had a wonderful experience...The Fall Specials were Amazing, Our waitress Luz was a pleasure & knew how to do her job & kudos to the bus boys...we came from NJ & it will NOT be our last. The complimentary platter of red crispy peppers, mushrooms, olives & cheeses was so kind & generous, hope you do not do away with it, really enjoyed it along with the delicious 😋 breads... How long will you offer the Fall Specials??? The 9oz Lobster tail was the best I ever had & the Soups had loads of clams, very generous...Your ambience along with everyone smiling was a welcome mat. The music 🎶 in the background was relaxing & pleasant. Looking forward to our next visit to City Island from NJ. Thank you fou your hospitality. FYI... Our Titos & Expresso Martini's were perfect...More infoSea Shore Restaurant & Marina$$$$• Seafood• City Island•4.6
- SSusanNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoFirst time there though we live in the neighborhood. Very happy with service, food and ambience. Fairly expensive but what isn’t these days. Would definitely go back and try the specials next time which are very reasonably priced.More infoLouie's Prime Steak & Seafood$$$$• Seafood• Port Washington•4.6
- AAlfredNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 7 days agoThe food and service was outstanding every time I have dined here.More infoATIK$$$$• Mediterranean• City Island•4.6
- CCarlos ENew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 21, 2026I gave FIVE STARS to Vistamar, because is a gorgeous and first-class place to enjoy a great time. Our waitress, Shadya, is a wonderful and kindly person, a diamond in the rough. ¡GRACIAS, SHADYA! Blessings for all the Vistamar staff. We’ll be back soon!More infoVistamar Restaurant & Lounge$$$$• Latin American• City Island•4.5
Trending dishes in City Island
Explore dishes that diners are raving about
Restaurant experiences trending in New York City
Discover more great restaurants
Private Dining
Find the perfect place for your next party or group dining event.
Explore private diningPrivate Dining
Find the perfect place for your next party or group dining event.
Get inspired by our collections of the top restaurants in City Island
Frequently asked questions
The best reviewed restaurant in City Island is City Island Pizza Company (opens in a new tab)
The restaurants with the best service in City Island are Sammy's Smokehouse BBQ & Grill (opens in a new tab), City Island Pizza Company (opens in a new tab) and Red Lobster - Bronx (opens in a new tab)
The restaurants with the best ambiance in City Island are City Island Pizza Company (opens in a new tab), ATIK (opens in a new tab) and Sammy's Smokehouse BBQ & Grill (opens in a new tab)
Explore OpenTable
- Home
- United States
- New York City