Book your reservation with us now for Father's Day! We'll have a special menu to celebrate all the great dads out there!
Sunday, June 17, 2018
Our waiter was pretty absent. But other than that it was good.
The food was great, place was a little chilly
There are a ton of choices for dining in downtown Libertyville and O'Tooles is usually a pretty good choice. I really think they are better for a microbrew with friends than for lunch / dinner. Last time we came in the wife had a craving for fish and chips and I was pretty open to to anything on the menu. The fish batter was pretty salty and my entree was luke warm. Sort of disappointing for a high end pub prices but I don't think it would stop us from stopping in again.
They forgot our food and so it took almost a hour before we were served. They did try to make it right on the bill by comping us our drinks
Food was delicious and service was amazing, despite the large Friday night crowd! We will be back!
working on preparing patio seating the night we visited -- seems like that is something that could have been done during the daylight hours. Created noise and activities that made our table uncomfortable. Tried bison meatloaf for the first time there - not too good , large portion covered in gravy but way too spicy . The usual great service and drinks
My 11 year old has celiac disease and the waitress did a good job in communicating the safer options for her on the gluten-sensitive menu, as well as explained how she would ask the kitchen to be sure to clean off the prep area and grill for my daughter's meal.
Great menu, diverse choices, large on tap beer menu. Service was excellent.
Uncooked carrots, uncooked cabbage and dried out tough corned
beef. Worst ever St. Patrick's Day meal.
O'Toole's has an authentic bar feel to it, but serves high quality food. It features an array of beer options and an abundance of TV screens.
Love O'Tooles! The food is great! We, on this occasion, made the mistake of sitting upstairs. Stage area where a small band of unattended children was running and screaming around all the tables. Parents of the kids didn't seem to care. O'Toole staff finally asked parents to control kids but it only lasted 10 minutes - then back to the screaming and running circles around our table.Staff did not return to ask them to stop again.
Will not eat upstairs again.
Good food and great beer selection at reasonable price. Noise was good and could converse without shouting.
It was a good dining experience. Good food. Lots of TV's. Went with my family on a Saturday evening.
Great food and a large beer selection.
Food was top notch.. surly darkness stout was on tap..Beer was awesome!! Bartenders and service is the best in Libertyville!!
O’Toole’s is one of regular spots. Decided last minute to go out on Valentine’s Day and was able to get in. Usually order regular pub fare but tonight tried a couple of the Valentine’s Day dinner specials. Very pleasantly surprised.
Great casual dining location with plenty of food choices.
Always love the food, beer and staff it makes for a great dinner or lunch out with friends and family.
gluten free burgers and fries we sat at the bar it was very nice loved it thx
Great food and friendly staff - perfect place to eat , drink and be merry
They need to change their menu
More often and offer specials .
Great flourless chocolate cake with Passion fruit sorbet!
My 5 year olds restaurant of choice for his birthday.
Not just your "bar" food. Unique selection and consistently good. Never disappointed.
The staff is always genuinely friendly and accommodating. We had been traveling all day
and was pleasantly surprised to find it open for a late dinner on New Years Day. Thank you
for being open. Happy New Year
Great place for a casual evening meal. Great atmosphere & service. Fantastic burgers & beer menu - so many choices. We'll be back!
Great food. Corey is the best executive chef around.
Really enjoyed the evening. Will definitely return on a regular basis.
Great beer selection - over 50 craft beers on draft. Reasonably priced food with good variety from entrees to burgers or flatbread. Good salad selection, but need more main meal choices for vegetarians. Could do without the TV screens ever few feet and a bit too noise for conversations with friends. Great decorations on the walls.
Good food, good service. Went there for business lunch. Great neighborhood place to go.
Our reserved table was ready when we arrived. Waitress had trouble communicating with one of our party due to noise level of restaurant, resulting in a missed drink order and difficulty understanding the food order. The errors were corrected. There was a bit of a wait for service and for food. The food was really excellent! We loved the Bistro tenderloin and the salad. The club sandwich ordered without tomato came with tomato, but after removal , it was also delicious. A second glass of wine was the wrong wine, again rectified immediately once it was brought to the waitress's attention. It was a very busy Friday night which contributed to the noise level. This is one of my favorite spots for lunch. Much less noise at that time. The menu here changes often with unique flavors and dishes, and the food is always top notch.
Nice setting with a good menu selection and
Good service in a comfortable setting with an excellent menu
A wonderful neighborhood place with great service and delicious food.
Waitress was great and food fantastic!
We arrived at 4 o'clock on Sunday afternoon. There were a lot of people eating outside in the courtyard. We prefer to eat inside which was quiet at first until some very loud people came in to watch the sports on the large TVs. My friend liked his bison burger and the large salad. I had a brisket sandwich that had said "smoke brisket" on the menu. It was not smoked and there were things like cheese, etc on it that were not listed on the menu. When the waitress asked me what I wanted for a side, I said the onion soup. She brought my friend his salad and disappeared. When she finally came by again, I asked for the soup. She said it comes on the platter with the sandwich. I told her to bring it now. She did, and it was OK. When she brought my "platter" there was an identical bowl on the platter filled with gravy for the sandwich. I guess she had never served that before. I was disappointed in the sandwich because it was not what the menu said it was and was pretty tasteless. They have many items on the menu. Too many! They should concentrate on quality, not quantity. We will not be going back there.
Good Food, nice Patio, and Jackie, our service was great!
The food was very disappointing. We had the soft pretzels (but they didn't come with cheese fondue as described), guacamole and salsa (pretty good guac), and fish tacos. The fish tacos had a strange taste which I think was actually old oil used to cook the taco shells...but not sure. It was really a disappointing meal, unfortunately. Perhaps the standard burger would have been a safer bet.
This is not bar food. It is above and beyond with an excellent beer and wine selection. We had the salmon burger which was very moist and fresh. Requested an outdoor seat and was seated immediately. Food is very very good and a unique variety. If you haven't tried you must.
Always a great place to go for drinks and dinner or lunch. Always taken care of very well.