4.9
- 4.9Food
- 4.9Service
- 4.7Ambience
- 4.6Value
Noise • Moderate
Our AI assistant, Concierge, is here to answer your questions about this restaurant.
OpenTable reviews from verified diners
Reviews from people who have dined at San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana.
4.9
Noise • Moderate
Wisconsin
Best Overall
Wisconsin
Best Food
Wisconsin
Hot spot
Milwaukee
Best Overall
Milwaukee
Best Food
Milwaukee
Hot spot
Jose Gold
Orlando20 reviews
Dined 4 days ago
Is this helpful?
reilly
Minneapolis2 reviews
Dined on May 1, 2026
Is this helpful?
Mike Gold
Milwaukee13 reviews
Dined on April 30, 2026
Is this helpful?
Amanda
Milwaukee11 reviews
Dined on April 25, 2026
Is this helpful?
James
Milwaukee3 reviews
Dined on April 22, 2026
Is this helpful?
Chad
Chicago6 reviews
Dined on April 19, 2026
Is this helpful?
David Gold
Milwaukee2 reviews
Dined on April 18, 2026
Is this helpful?
Graham
Chicago1 review
Dined on April 15, 2026
Is this helpful?
Michael Gold
Milwaukee5 reviews
Dined on April 12, 2026
Is this helpful?
Todd
Chicago1 review
Dined on April 10, 2026
Is this helpful?
November 15, 2024
LoveFood named the Milwaukee spot the best pizza place in Wisconsin, praising its authentic Neapolitan pies. It bakes dough in a 900°F wood-fired oven for a chewy, charred crust.
Published in iHeart
August 22, 2024
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana is listed at No. 86 on Yelp's Top 100 Pizza Spots in the Midwest for 2024. The roundup highlights Wisconsin's strong pizza scene, including several Neapolitan-style offerings.
Published in Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Yes, San Giorgio is a popular choice for date night. Guests praise the lively, intimate atmosphere and many recommend sitting at the pizza/oven bar for a front‑row view of pizzas being made, which makes for a fun, romantic experience. It’s casual‑elegant and often busy, so reserve a table and consider an early seating if you prefer a quieter meal. Expect authentic Neapolitan pizza, shareable appetizers, and attentive service for a memorable evening out.
Portions are generally moderate and designed for sharing. Guests describe the pizzas as personal/neapolitan sizes (around 10–12 inches), often fine to split between two people, while salads and appetizers (arancini, eggplant fries) are generous and meant to share. If you’re especially hungry, order an extra starter or pair a salad with a pizza.
Family‑friendly: yes, guests often bring teens, celebrate birthdays, and large youth groups have been accommodated. The team is praised for being patient and flexible with changing reservations. Accessibility-specific details aren’t provided in the available information, so call ahead to confirm wheelchair access or other accommodations.
Go early on a weekday evening for a quieter experience (Tue–Thu right at opening) or arrive before showtime if you’re dining before an event. Fri and Sat nights are busiest and lively, great if you want energy, but expect noise and full capacity. Reservations are strongly recommended to avoid being turned away.
The atmosphere is lively, buzzing, and authentically Italian, many guests say it feels like being in Naples. Expect energetic background chatter, warm service, and the theatrical draw of a wood‑fired oven and pizza prep counter. It’s casual‑elegant and perfect for a fun night out, though it can be loud when full.
Casual dress is appropriate. Guests commonly dine in comfortable, casual attire while enjoying a slightly elevated, modern pizzeria experience.
Yes, the team is frequently noted as accommodating. Guests report the restaurant handles reservation changes and large groups well, and there are positive mentions of gluten‑free pizza options. For seating preferences (oven bar, table) or dietary needs, call ahead to confirm availability and let staff know your request.
Generally, yes, families and multi‑generation groups dine here, and guests have celebrated birthdays with children and teens. The menu and atmosphere are casual enough for families, though the space is small and can get noisy, so an early seating may be better with younger kids.
Busiest: Fri–Sat evenings and nights when there are nearby events (games, shows), guests report a lively, crowded scene. Quietest: early weekday dinners (Tue–Thu at opening) tend to be calmer. If you prefer a low‑key meal, choose midweek and earlier times.
If you want the most relaxed visit, choose a midweek evening (Tue–Thu) when the restaurant is typically less crowded. For a lively, high‑energy night, Fri or Sat is ideal, just book ahead since those nights fill up quickly.
There’s no formal holiday schedule provided, but guests have reported dining there on New Year’s Eve, so the restaurant has been open on at least some holidays. Holiday hours likely vary, call ahead to confirm special hours or availability for a specific date.
How FAQ content is generated