Surf & Sirloin
Our server was terrible. He couldn’t remember anything we asked for.
The tables were nicely spaced. The food was excellent. Our server worked very hard to meet our needs. Even though every table was filled, each family was able to enjoy their party in a quiet atmosphere.
Went here for the first time for Father’s Day. Excellent food and great service.
Service and food was outstanding.
Enjoyed the meal.
The meal was absolutely amazing. Lobster, crab, and shrimp were wonderful. The filet will melt in your mouth. Salad and foster potatoes were delicious. Awesome service.
Although there was a lot of room in the restaurant, we let us to a small booth by the bar. The room was, and continue to, be very loud. There were three of us and the other two enjoyed their meal. My steak was at least 1/3 gristle and inedible. The prices are higher than what you would expect for the same food and service.
Celebrating my wife’s final radiation treatment for cancer. Everything was great. Our dinner was a memorable experience.
Service was excellent. Anthony was attentive, but not overbearing. Food was delicious. Everyone in our table of five was extremely satisfied with the dinner and service.
The food and service were good. However, the place was very dated. The bathroom, while clean ( which is most important), was worn with broken tiles. I know restaurants are hurting after being shut down due to COVID so hoping when things improve that a refresh becomes a priority.
Surf & Sirloin never disappoints. Stavro and Hamm are keeping the family tradition alive and well.
Had exceptional service from Austin last night and the food was great. My steak was cooked exactly the way I like it and the Foster potatoes were a nice change. A very nice place. Will be back again.
Took the family out and we enjoyed ourselves. A tad bit noisy, but I think it was a lot of graduation celebrations. Food was delicious, especially the crab cakes and oysters.
Excellent food . Wonderful service very friendly. We.
Thoroughly enjoyed our evening
We went for an anniversary dinner. Amazing food and service.
We had a great meal - salad, entree and dinner were excellent, and the service was outstanding.
Food was fabulous! Atmosphere was great! Service was fantastic!
Surf & Sirloin has a varied and upscale menu. There aren't many places where you can find escargot and grilled octopus appetizers. Their fish dishes are generally very good and nicely prepared. Steaks are always a good choice.
As always, a very pleasant evening with excellent food! The Karagiannis family always delivers!
First time visitors, we enjoyed our dinner! Service was great, and the atmosphere was friendly and welcoming. we loved the appetizer (cajun shrimp) and our cocktails were made to order.
We had the fish special-which was 'good' but somewhat bland. We were not disappointed-and will be back to try other items from the menu!
The food was forgetable.
Service was slow.
Dining room is dated.
Don't mind paying for a premium experience. But that's not what I received.
It should be acknowledged that staffing at most restaurants has been negatively impacted by COVID-19 . The same is true at Surf & Sirloin. However, service is generally lackluster, food is OK-not great, and ambiance is mediocre, without energy.
The food is very good, but we will not be back. We noted on Open Table we were celebrating a 60th wedding anniversary, and we mentioned it to the hostess. But there was ZERO acknowledgment of the very special anniversary. Besides that, this place is very dated- it really needs a face lift. Its a shame because the food is very good. We have no problem paying a premium for a great dining experience, but there is no “experience”here.
Just the right amount of food
Horrible server (Austin) and service. Reserved over one week for Mother’s Day, upon arrival, had to wait 5-10 minutes before seated. Server was loud and inattentive to details (no straw, forgot beverage) and debated about charging for a lemonade because of wife (on Mother’s Day) adding lemon and “sugar free” packets to water, a manager corrected the server. Overall, server put a damper on dinner, had to speak with manager to correct server and mention service. No plans to return!
Mother’s Day Brunch was a hit at Surf & Sirloin. They easily accommodated five people and our table was ready right on time aligning with our reservation. The service was excellent as was the food. And the menu was quite extensive with plenty of choices to suit everyone’s desires. The dining area could use some updates, but when the food and service are this good, that is a minor issue. We’ll definitely be back! Thanks for a great day!
New Orleans Shrimp appetizer and pepper tenderloins were excellent,
And one of the few places to get the famous and good Mayfair Dressing Salade
Nice place! A experienced professional staff. All was great for Mother’s Day Brunch.
Steaks created to perfect temperature and they were flavorful.
The Food was so Amazing as well as the service our server she was great we will be back great place
Our server was not friendly and borderline rude. For the money we spent I was pretty disappointed! We asked to split the check between two couples and he refused said it was on the menu no split checks which isn’t wasn’t- it said specifically parties of six or more which we weren’t. It doesn’t seem like it would have been difficult considering our $300+ check! I doubt I will be going back here anytime soon!
Food was ok, waitress was super friendly. A little overpriced for being mediocre.
Excellent food and service. Highest quality meat and seafood offerings.
The lobster was over cooked and tough.
Wine list by the glass was a little sparse, understandable when business is slow, you don't want a bunch of open bottles getting stale. But we managed to get very nice wines. The salads were only average. Entrees were very good; I had the scallops (out of the veal chop), and my wife had the special steak with shrimp and scallops. Sides were also excellent.
I downgraded ambience as there was only one other couple there (we were well spaced) and a power outage to boot, both not entirely their fault.
I recommend Surf and Sirloin.
Just ok, would choose something different the next time I’m looking for a date night.
Scottish Salmon and Rib-eye delicious!
The food is great. We were seated in a corner. There were 2 couples seated after us, they took both of their orders first. It was very loud. It seemed like no one knew what inside voices were. I chose this for a birthday dinner and they did not wish her a Happy Birthday. Not expecting anything but why ask?
Again the steak was great and perfectly prepared. If you are looking for romantic it is a bit loud and not a romantic atmosphere.
Food was very good but not enough staff to get prompt service or food prep.
Surf & Sirloin offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (314) 822-3637.
Surf & Sirloin is rated 4.4 stars by 261 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.