Raw Bar
1/2 Dozen Littleneck Clams*$18.00
Chilled Jumbo Shrimp
- ea.$5.50
Yellowtail Ceviche*$22.00
yuzu, pink grapefruit, ancho chili, toasted garlic
Tuna Tartare*$22.00
avocado, cucumber, crispy wontons
Baby Grand Platter*$42.00
six clams, six oysters, tuna crudo
Grand Platter*$79.00
twelve oysters, six clams, tuna crudo, shrimp cocktail, salmon tartare
Today's Oysters - East Coast
Chunu* (Eastern Shore, VA)$3.50
slight brine, sweet, earthy finish
Mermaid Cove* (Pei, CA)$3.75
briny, tender meat
Island Creek* (Duxbury, MA)$4.00
zesty brine, plump firm meat
East Beach Blonde* (Ninigret, RI)$4.25
salt & peachy finish
Pink Moon* (Pei, Ca)$3.75
sweet & salty finish
Today's Oysters - West Coast
Chef's Choice Oyster*
Appetizers
New England Clam Chowder$14.00
bacon & fingerling potatoes
Delicata Squash Salad$18.00
squash, boston lettuce, parmesan & sunflower seeds
Butternut Squash Risotto$19.00
squash, parmesan cheese & pumpkin seeds
Lobster Knuckles "Escargot Stye"$21.00
parsley garlic butter, grilled country bread
Seared Calamari Salad$20.00
cremini, shiitake, frisee, olive oil & lemon
Shaved Kale Salad$18.00
house caesar, parmesan, garlic croutons, old bay chick peas
Prince Edward Island Mussels$21.00
white sauce, fresh herbs & grilled country bread
Entrees
Pan Seared Salmon$32.00
butternut squash puree, shaved brussels sprouts & salsa verde
Mermaid Fish Tacos$29.00
beer batter, red cabbage, pickled jalapeño, pico de gallo
Linguine & Clams$30.00
arugula, meyer lemon, aleppo pepper
Pan seared Halibut$35.00
corn puree, jalapeno bread & pineaplle salsa fresca
Pan Roasted Free Range Chicken$30.00
broccolini, fingerling potatoes & roasted peppers
Wild Yellowfin Tuna Tataki*$33.00
rainbow cauliflower rice, almonds & lemongrass sauce
"Nearly Famous" Lobster Roll$39.00
grilled brioche bun & old bay fries
14 oz New York Strip Steak$44.00
chimichurri, sea salt & smashed fingerling
San Francisco "Style" Seafood Cioppino$33.00
clams, mussels, white fish, calamari, shrimp & tomato saffron broth
Simply Grilled Fish
olive oil, sea salt, lemon
True North Salmon$26.00
Halibut$30.00
Whole Branzino$36.00
Sides & Veggies
Roasted Carrots$14.00
goat cheese & pistachios
Hush Puppies$12.00
corn & hot pepper honey
Parker House Rolls$8.00
old bay, drawn butter, sea salt
Crispy Smashed Fingerling$11.00
salsa verde
Smoked Gouda Mac & Cheese$14.00
Old Bay Fries$10.00
House Salad$13.00
parmesan, carrot, red onnion, radish, lemon citronette
Fried Brussels Sprouts$13.00
sherry & bacon
White
Sancerre, Vignobles Edonis La Muse, 2025 (Loire, FR)$22.00
- Bottle$86.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Three Brooms 2025 (Marlborough, NZ)$17.00
- Bottle$66.00
Chablis, Michel Laroche Et Ses Enfants 2024 (Burgundy, FR)$20.00
- Bottle$78.00
Gruner, L&T Weingut Brundelmayer 2024 (Langenois, AU)$17.00
- Bottle$66.00
Gavi di Gavi, Tenuata, San Giacomo 2025 (Piemonte, IT)$16.00
- Bottle$62.00
Albarino Rias Baixas, Pazo Torre 2024 (Galicia SP)$16.00
- Bottle$62.00
Chardonnay, Lava Cap 2024 (El Dorado, CA)$18.00
- Bottle$70.00
Red
Pinot Noir, Balverne Be Forever Wild 2022 (Russian River Valley, CA)$17.00
- Bottle$62.00
Barbera D'Alba, Punset 2024 (Piedmont, IT)$15.00
- Bottle$58.00
Sangiovese, Pietro Caciorgna, 2022 (Tuscany, IT)$17.00
- Bottle$66.00
Valpolicella, Speri, Chilled Wine 2024 (Veneto, IT)$16.00
- Bottle$62.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Scaia Torre Mellotti 2021 (Piedmont, IT)$18.00
- Bottle$70.00
Sparkling
Prosecco, Ca'furlan NV (Veneto, IT)$16.00
- Bottle$62.00
Cava Conquilla (Catalonia, SP)$15.00
- Bottle$58.00
Lambrusco, Frico Scarpetta NV (Emelia-Romania, IT)$15.00
Rosé
Chateau de Pourcieux 2025 (Provence, FR)$18.00
- Bottle$62.00
Peyrassol la Croix 2025 (Provence, FR)$16.00
- Bottle$54.00
Cocktails
$17
Mezcalita$17.00
chipotle infused mezcal, pineapple, ginger & lime
Pear With Me$17.00
vodka, pear puree, lemon & cinnamon
Hibiscus Mule$17.00
vodka, hibiscus, lime & ginger
Blood Orange Hospitality$17.00
jalapeño-infused tequila, blood orange & lime
Autumn Sweater$17.00
spiced bourbon, apple cider, lemon & honey
Mermaid's Merigold$17.00
gin, aperol, tangerine, lemon & honey
Casa J Passion fruit Martini$20.00
casa j tequila, passion fruit, lemon & vanilla
Mermaid Martini Flight$25.00
dirty martini, cosmopolitan & espresso martini
On Tap
Montauk Surf Golden Ale 4.5%$10.00
Montauk, NY
Estrella Galicia Lager 5.4%$10.00
Galicia, SP
Montauk Wavechaser IPA 6.4 %$10.00
Montauk, NY
Bottles/Cans
Montauk Pilsner 5.4%$12.00
Montauk Brewing, New York
Belgian Wheat Ale 6.4%$12.00
Montauk Brewing, New York
Premium Lager 4.8%$12.00
Forst Brewery, Italy
Hazy IPA, 6.2%$12.00
Founders Brewing Co, Mitchigan
Happy Hour Food
4:30 pm to 6:00 pm
Chef's Choice Oyster*$2.00
minimum of 6
Little Neck Clams*$2.00
minimum of 6
Mini New England Clam Chowder$4.00
Salmon Tartare*$10.00
Mini Mermaid Fish Taco$4.00
Spinach & Artichoke Dip$9.00
Fried Calamari$12.00
Grilled Shrimp & Avocado Slider$9.00
Happy Hour Cocktails
4:30 to 6pm $12
Daiquiri
rum, agave, lime
Margarita
tequila, triple sec, lime
Hugo Spritz
blanc de blancs, elderflower, mint
Pink Flamingo
gin, pamplemousse, cranberry, lemon
Hot & Dirty
vodka, olive juice, peppadew, hot sauce
N/A Beer
Athletic N/A Upside Dawn Golden Ale$10.00
Stanford, CT 12 oz
Montauk IPA N/A$10.00
Montauk, Ny 12 oz
Zero Proof Cocktails
Blood Orange Refresher$12.00
pineapple, blood orange, lime
Mojito$12.00
blood orange - passion fruit - pineapple - cucumber
Spicy Pineapple Margarita $12.00
jalapeño, pineapple, lime
Mermaid Kiss$12.00
hibiscus, ginger, lime
Porn Star Mock-tini$12.00
passion fruit, lime, vanilla, soda