17 Best Burgers Restaurants In Middle Island

17 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Dockside Brewery

4.6

Exceptional(790)

$$$$

• Burgers • Milford

Booked 49 times today

Excellent as usual. Our server Madison was excellent.

A photo of White Castle - Centereach restaurant

2. White Castle - Centereach

4.9

Exceptional(23)

$$$$

• Burgers • Nesconset

It was a wonderful way to celebrate Valentine's Day. Over the top festuve

A photo of Sayville Falls Mini Golf and Beer Garden restaurant

3. Sayville Falls Mini Golf and Beer Garden

4.6

Exceptional(13)

$$$$

• Burgers • Sayville

It was a great place to come hang out after a tournament day!

Icon

4. The Whelk

4.5

Awesome(407)

$$$$

• Burgers • Westport

Booked 21 times today

What a fantastic restaurant! Gorgeous setting, our waiter was superb, the food was fabulous! Great experience! Can't wait to return!

A photo of Dave & Buster's - Islandia (Long Island) restaurant

5. Dave & Buster's - Islandia (Long Island)

4.4

Awesome(96)

$$$$

• Burgers • Hauppauge

Booked 4 times today

10/10 man the waitstaff was awesome, every little thing I asked for they did without hesitation my daughter had a great 10th birthday celebration I will definitely be returning….

A photo of Bonfire Grille - Milford restaurant

6. Bonfire Grille - Milford

4.5

Awesome(23)

$$$$

• Burgers • Milford

Booked 4 times today

Food and entertainment were great! Service was very timely and staff are friendly. Be sure to make a reservation. If we didn’t we would have had to wait to be seated.

7. Vauxhall

4.5

Awesome(13)

$$$$

• Burgers • Huntington

Booked 2 times today

I’ve been to Vauxhall many times now, whether it’s for a sit-down meal or just a quick drink at the bar, and I’ve never been disappointed! The service is consistently exceptional, and the staff always makes every guest feel welcome and well taken care of. Special shoutout to Danielle, Emily, and Jay behind the bar, who always go above and beyond to make every visit a great experience! That being said, the entire staff is truly incredible, and their hospitality is a huge part of what makes this place so special. I have yet to try anything on the menu that was less than delicious (special shoutout to their mac & cheese and BBQ quesadilla!). Whether you’re in the mood for a casual drink, a great meal, or a fun night out, Vauxhall always delivers. I truly can’t recommend this place enough!

A photo of Main Event - Deer Park restaurant

8. Main Event - Deer Park

4.0

Excellent(2)

$$$$

• Burgers • Deer Park

Booked 5 times today

Main Event is your premier destination for chef-inspired dining and legendary entertainment, featuring a mouth-watering menu of fan favorites and a full-service bar stocked with innovative cocktails! Whether our hand-stretched pizzas or signature sliders fuel you, the excitement continues with state-of-the-art bowling, laser tag, and hundreds of the latest arcade games. Plus, with massive HDTVs throughout the venue, you won’t miss a second of the big game while you eat, bowl, and play.

A photo of Match Burger Lobster restaurant

9. Match Burger Lobster

4.1

Excellent(358)

$$$$

• Burgers • Westport

Food is always yummy! Love the indoor/outdoor seating.

A photo of Emmy Squared Pizza - Westport restaurant

10. Emmy Squared Pizza - Westport

4.2

Awesome(158)

$$$$

• Burgers • Westport

Booked 8 times today

Service was great & food was delicious! Happy night for kiddos & parents

Best Burgers Restaurants in Middle Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

17 restaurants available nearby

1. Dockside Brewery

2. White Castle - Centereach

3. Sayville Falls Mini Golf and Beer Garden

4. The Whelk

5. Dave & Buster's - Islandia (Long Island)

6. Bonfire Grille - Milford

7. Vauxhall

8. Main Event - Deer Park

9. Match Burger Lobster

10. Emmy Squared Pizza - Westport

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable