11 Best Italian Restaurants In Cooperstown

11 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Cacciatores Italian Steakhouse restaurant

1. Cacciatores Italian Steakhouse

4.7

Exceptional(9)

$$$$

• Italian • Ilion

Booked 1 time today

Great Menu, delicious dinner. Waitress is great, and make you feel welcome.

A photo of Godfather's Hideout restaurant

2. Godfather's Hideout

4.9

Exceptional(42)

$$$$

• Italian • Herkimer

Booked 6 times today

This is a family owned business. The food was fantastic and the service was impeccable. I would highly recommend this restaurant.

A photo of Roman's at the View restaurant

3. Roman's at the View

4.5

Awesome(132)

$$$$

• Italian • Utica

Booked 12 times today

Since opening a year ago, we have probably been to Romans no fewer than 20 times and have never been disappointed. The service, food and ambience who’s outstanding. The Wednesday raw bar in the summer has the best raw clams and oysters I’ve ever had.

A photo of Pino Bianco at Turning Stone restaurant

4. Pino Bianco at Turning Stone

4.5

Awesome(4215)

$$$$

• Italian • Verona

Booked 31 times today

The service and meal were wonderful as always! I can’t wait to go again.

A photo of Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse - Utica restaurant

5. Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse - Utica

4.6

Exceptional(735)

$$$$

• Italian • Utica

Booked 15 times today

Everything was wonderful from beginning to end! Our server, Eric, was extremely attentive and personal. Our food was delicious and made exactly as ordered. Great ambiance, great experience!

6. Ancora!

4.9

Exceptional(654)

$$$$

• Italian • Utica

Booked 13 times today

The BEST Haddoc Oreganata I have ever had! Instead of it swimming in butter and lemon, it has a delightful lemon aioli drizzed perfectly over the top. The parmesan risotto compliments the dish perfectly.

A photo of Portofino Restaurant & Events restaurant

7. Portofino Restaurant & Events

3.8

Excellent(194)

$$$$

• Italian • Utica

Booked 5 times today

At first we weren’t sure about the restaurant as our reservation was for 5 pm but the front doors were locked. My husband wanted to leave but I said let me call and the young lady who answered said I’ll be right there to open them. So after getting in and taken to our table which was lovely and the atmosphere was great. Our waitress Shelly was wonderful from the start of the meal till the end. The food was very good except that the steak was a bit overcooked and had bites of grizzle, flavor was good. Anyway overall a positive dining experience!

A photo of Chesterfield's Tavolo restaurant

8. Chesterfield's Tavolo

4.8

Exceptional(480)

$$$$

• Italian • Utica

Booked 5 times today

Hostess is always friendly, food is excellent and exceptionally consistent from visit to visit. Fair prices given quality of meal and great service. Keep up the great job…..don’t lose your way like other have.

9. Carmella's Cafe

3.6

Very Good(80)

$$$$

• Italian • Utica

Hostess wasn’t aware you could make OpenTable reservations. We were seated promptly and placed drink and app order. Drinks and bread arrived shortly afterwards. They offer a daily early bird special(as of 9/26) from 3-5:30 daily. Consists of drinks - sodas, tea/coffee; soup or salad and choice of 6 entrees from 2 different price structures. Also included is a bowl of chocolate or vanilla ice cream or mini cannoli. Ordered the deluxe app - Buratta with fresh tomatoes, onions and fresh basil. Soup we picked: minestrone and Chickarina; entrees: Fettuccine Alfredo and grilled Alpine chicken. Dessert was the cannolis. Great value, food was tasty and service was excellent. Adding to our restaurants when we are in the Utica area.

10. Jadie & Junes

4.5

Awesome(127)

$$$$

• Italian • Oneida

Booked 29 times today

Great dinner. The food was great. No complaints. Staff kind and attentive.

Best Italian Restaurants in Cooperstown

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

11 restaurants available nearby

1. Cacciatores Italian Steakhouse

2. Godfather's Hideout

3. Roman's at the View

4. Pino Bianco at Turning Stone

5. Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse - Utica

6. Ancora!

7. Portofino Restaurant & Events

8. Chesterfield's Tavolo

9. Carmella's Cafe

10. Jadie & Junes

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable