14 Best Italian Restaurants In Cartago

14 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Olive Garden - Lincoln Plaza restaurant

1. Olive Garden - Lincoln Plaza

4.1

Excellent(61)

$$$$

• Italian • Heredia

Booked 7 times today

Well what can I say we had a very very good experience the food is really delicious! and the service is impressive how kind they are especially Liliana.

2. Caffe Negroni

4.6

Exceptional(261)

$$$$

• Italian • Escazu

Booked 12 times today

Wonderful! This is my favorite restaurant in San Jose and I always look forward to dining here when in town!

A photo of Olive Garden Aleste restaurant

3. Olive Garden Aleste

4.5

Awesome(621)

$$$$

• Italian • Curridabat

Booked 9 times today

Great experience and the service was outstanding! Our server, Gaby, was on point with the order and very aware of any need.

A photo of Olive Garden Escazú Village restaurant

4. Olive Garden Escazú Village

4.4

Awesome(1610)

$$$$

• Italian • San José

Booked 6 times today

Table was ready when the party arrived and service was excellent

A photo of Bacchus Ristorante restaurant

5. Bacchus Ristorante

4.7

Exceptional(51)

$$$$

• Italian • Santa Ana

Booked 11 times today

Excellent, great service and delicious food. It's a higher end place, so keep that in mind, but it was absolutely worth it for us!

A photo of Olive Garden Terrazas Lindora restaurant

6. Olive Garden Terrazas Lindora

4.4

Awesome(1268)

$$$$

• Italian • San José

Booked 4 times today

As usual, our experience was great. Little to no waiting time. As we were with two kids, they offered us a booth so we would be more comfortable, so shout out to the staff for acting so fast in that regard. We were greeted well at the table, and served took the order within 5 mins of being sat down, food was delivered almost instantly, no more than 10 min wait time. The only issue I would raise is that some of the food was cold, and since the air conditioner was on, food got colder quite fast. We were sitted in a section with a large group at the opposite table, so server had to juggle a bit more to accommodate everyone’s requirement in our sitted section. Despite all this, it’s still a great experience and enjoy going there as a family

7. Terrazza Toscana

4.4

Awesome(56)

$$$$

• Italian • Escazu

As always food quality is kept and the environment is so relaxed. Great service and friendly staff.

A photo of Sapore Trattoria - Curridabat restaurant

8. Sapore Trattoria - Curridabat

4.3

Awesome(14)

$$$$

• Italian • Curridabat

Booked 1 time today

Excellent service and good price quality ratio. The artisanal beer is excellent

A photo of Fogo Rodizio - Escazú restaurant

9. Fogo Rodizio - Escazú

4.1

Excellent(18)

$$$$

• Italian • Escazu

The food was delicious and the place is wonderful. Nice service at the table

10. Gusto Lindora

4.8

Exceptional(51)

$$$$

• Italian • San José

Our favorite restaurant, incredible people with even better food. We drive 1hr to get there, thats how much we like it. They need to open one in Pinares so we can visit. Highly recommend it!

Best Italian Restaurants in Cartago

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

14 restaurants available nearby

1. Olive Garden - Lincoln Plaza

2. Caffe Negroni

3. Olive Garden Aleste

4. Olive Garden Escazú Village

5. Bacchus Ristorante

6. Olive Garden Terrazas Lindora

7. Terrazza Toscana

8. Sapore Trattoria - Curridabat

9. Fogo Rodizio - Escazú

10. Gusto Lindora

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable