Best Italian Restaurants in Lancaster

Giancarlo’s was AMAZING! Hands down, some of the best food I’ve ever had! Yes, it’s a little pricey, but the taste, the energy, the atmosphere, and the overall vibe made every penny worth it. Everything was top tier! They even went the extra mile and had a personalized menu made with my name on it for my birthday. Those little touches really make a difference. Thank you for making my birthday special and giving me such a great experience. Definitely a 10/10! I’ll absolutely be back! ❤️

Excellent service and high quality food. I always recommend the Rizzo's Signature Red (get a bottle, you will thank me), as well as the veal parm, the gnocchi and the caeser salad (enough for 4). You cannot leave without the brownie desert with the mint chocolate chip ice cream (enough for 4). Enjoy!

My fiancé and I decided to try Lucia’s for the first time. This was our last anniversary as an unmarried couple and what a phenomenal experience it was. Thomas provided some of the best service we have ever had. The food and cocktails were as great as he was. Everything we ordered delivered and even exceeded what we had expected. We cannot wait to make this a yearly (at least) place for us!

We dine there a few times a year as we are from Rochester. It is always an amazing experience and the food is absolutely delicious.

We enjoyed a nice family (6) evening dinner. First time there for some of us. The food was very good and menu was a nice variety.