Best Spanish Restaurants in Fishers Island

Dinner was great as always. Highly recommend the skirt steak.

Enjoyed our dinner. Food was great. Atmosphere really nice.

This place truly surprised me! I’ve been seeing it all over social media, and it looked so nice that my friends and I decided to check it out for a Thursday girls’ night. Walking in, I was immediately impressed by the beautiful decor and overall vibe! The drinks were good, except for the margarita I ordered, which surprisingly had seltzer in it. I can’t have carbonation, and when I asked about it, our server insisted that’s how margaritas are made—which I know isn’t the case. Aside from that, the menu had an interesting mix of options, but the food was actually AMAZING! 10/10 for the food! The DJ played great music, the atmosphere was fun, and we really enjoyed ourselves. I would definitely return for another night!

Reslly great food and vibe Drinks were also excellent

Always a great experience at Plancha! Delicious small plates designed for sharing with excellent service from Danielle and Brian. We had the octopus, the duck breast special with a Madeira wine sauce that was drinkable on its own, and the chicken cordon blue sandwich and a great bottle of Tempranillo. So good and such a great local gem to savor and enjoy.