10 Best Traditional Mexican Restaurants In New Milford

10 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Mexcal

4.5

Awesome(179)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Englewood

Booked 10 times today

Best guac in Bergen County. Great service and food service/delivery is outstanding. Never disappoints.

A photo of El Asadero Mexican Grill - Rochelle Park restaurant

2. El Asadero Mexican Grill - Rochelle Park

4.5

Awesome(349)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Rochelle Park

Booked 7 times today

We were celebrating a birthday and wedding anniversary and wanted to try something different. I drive by often and wanted to try it. The food was delicious and the service was very good. It was a lively atmosphere, and we had a very nice time.

A photo of La Fortaleza - Lodi restaurant

3. La Fortaleza - Lodi

4.5

Awesome(39)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Lodi

Booked 6 times today

Absolutely a beautiful party from beginning to end! Especially now that we're in the Halloween season and all of the Day of the decorations, the cutout cars you can have a seat in and eat in the drinks, the food, the quality and the quantity all outstanding!

A photo of La Fortaleza - Carlstadt restaurant

4. La Fortaleza - Carlstadt

4.5

Awesome(53)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • East Rutherford

Booked 3 times today

Love this place very authentic Mexican food live music and the ambience was super nice love how everything is decorated Lo recomiendo mucho es súper nice para fotos la comida excelente y mucha variedad 👍🏼👍🏼🔥👍🏼

A photo of Bitol Mexican Kitchen & Handcrafted Cantina Home restaurant

5. Bitol Mexican Kitchen & Handcrafted Cantina Home

4.8

Exceptional(482)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Clifton

Booked 4 times today

Food and service were great! The drinks were delicious. Decor was very cool.

A photo of El Asadero Mexican Grill Fort Lee restaurant

6. El Asadero Mexican Grill Fort Lee

4.1

Excellent(12)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Fort Lee

Booked 1 time today

the service was hospitable and attentive.the food was delicious. A great location for walking around. Highly recommend.

A photo of Pico De Gallo Bar & Kitchen restaurant

7. Pico De Gallo Bar & Kitchen

4.5

Awesome(53)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Upper West Side

Booked 1 time today

Tasty food in a very nice place. Good music and friendly servers.

A photo of La Fortaleza - Clifton restaurant

8. La Fortaleza - Clifton

4.1

Excellent(16)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Clifton

Booked 2 times today

I went for a dia de los muertos sip and paint. Food Margherita and service was amazing. Live music was great . Painting staff was so attentive. Great night out with friends.

9. Arre Sinaloa

4.6

Exceptional(21)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Union City

Booked 1 time today

Unbelievable find. Can’t wait to come back. Some of the best food and cocktails I’ve had in the area. A true gem.

A photo of Mexicocina Mezcaleria restaurant

10. Mexicocina Mezcaleria

(0)

$$$$

• Traditional Mexican • Mott Haven

Mexicocina is a cozy, authentic Mexican restaurant. Known for excellent birria tacos, consommé, handmade tortillas, and flavorful street-style dishes. It also offers a solid mezcal and tequila selection in a welcoming neighborhood vibe.

Best Traditional Mexican Restaurants in New Milford

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

10 restaurants available nearby

1. Mexcal

2. El Asadero Mexican Grill - Rochelle Park

3. La Fortaleza - Lodi

4. La Fortaleza - Carlstadt

5. Bitol Mexican Kitchen & Handcrafted Cantina Home

6. El Asadero Mexican Grill Fort Lee

7. Pico De Gallo Bar & Kitchen

8. La Fortaleza - Clifton

9. Arre Sinaloa

10. Mexicocina Mezcaleria

Explore OpenTable