Best Authentic Restaurants in Oyster Pond
Price
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
16 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
Booked 10 times today
See what locals rave about
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- MmichaelGoldNew York City •115 reviews5.0Dined 5 days agoEven if you are not in a romantic mood when you enter to dine fabulously, you will be upon departing! This is one of the jewels for Italian in the whole Caribbean. Marco, the venerable and famous patron, has created a place of refinement and excellence. The pastas are perfectly cooked with the Carbonara being unbelievable. Formerly this lovely dish was only a special order, but now we fortunate diners may indulge every evening. Another absolute highlight is the cool and refreshing seafood salad. Many patrons only come for this luxurious assortment of beautiful seafood salad. Cocktails are an art here and should not be missed with Hugo’s and various martinis just superb! Thank you Milos!More infoRoma Restaurant Cucina Italiana$$$$• Italian• Maho•4.7
- NNickSaint Martin •1 review5.0Dined on Oct 29, 2026We started off a French martini and a Woodford old-fashioned that were both excellent! For our appetizer, we went with the mushroom ravioli, and they were fantastic! My wife had the trigger fish with brown rice in a butter and almond sauce. I had the seared scallops with rigatoni. Both our meals were spectacular.. We finished it off with their chocolate lava cake. It was a perfect meal, all and all! We are on the island here every year for my wife’s birthday and always make it a point to go to La VillaMore infoLa Villa Restaurant€€€€• French• Grand Case•4.9
- DDonnaAtlantic City / South Jersey Shore •8 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 22, 2026Toppers has delicious hamburgers and the very reasonable priced! Drinks are very good!! They also walk around with their flavored rum to taste test! Thursday night is karaoke- be ready to sing and laugh! Great experience, service and food!!More infoTopper's$$$$• International• Pelican Key•4.5
- AAnneSouth Carolina •18 reviews5.0Dined on Aug 16, 2026This restaurant was fabulous. The ambiance was nice and the food fresh and hot. The portions are American sized. The presentation of the food was great.More infoLe Moulin Fou$$$$• French• Maho•4.6
- PPriscillaGoldRaleigh / Durham / Chapel Hill •2 reviews5.0Dined on Jul 28, 2026We had a wonderful dinner at Alizé! The service was excellent, and the view was absolutely beautiful. The cocktail special was delicious, the octopus appetizer was outstanding, and both the fish special and the filet were cooked perfectly. Everything was fresh and flavorful. We highly recommend Alizé for a great meal and a beautiful evening!More infoAliz退€€• International• Marigot•4.6