78 Best Cozy Restaurants in Gettysburg

78 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Mansion House 1757 restaurant

1. Mansion House 1757

4.6

Exceptional(734)

$$$$

• American • Gettysburg

Booked 5 times today

Food, service and atmosphere was great! Highly recommend

A photo of The Smokehouse Restaurant at Antrim 1844 restaurant

2. The Smokehouse Restaurant at Antrim 1844

4.9

Exceptional(832)

$$$$

• Contemporary French / American • Taneytown

Booked 9 times today

The Smokehouse Restaurant in Taneytown is truly a gem! Its beautiful historic charm, wonderful atmosphere, delicious food, and outstanding service make it a special place for any occasion. It’s warm, welcoming, and full of character. The perfect place to celebrate life’s special moments. Highly recommend!

3. Wye Oak Tavern

4.7

Exceptional(1178)

$$$$

• American • Frederick

Booked 59 times today

We drove over from The Inn Boonsboro which is a bit of a trek for dinner on winding roads and I-70 but it was worth it. The food was really great, our server Mary was wonderful and the look of the restaurant was inviting and contemporary. At some point the restaurant was a church which gives it a great vibe but the bar, while quite dramatic, might be considered a bit sacrilegious, with its behind the alter painting and religious architectural elements, but it sure is beautiful. Also, finding street parking, even on a Wednesday night, was impossible. Thankfully the restaurant has "valet" parking for $8. They take credit cards. Lastly, there's a new hotel attached to the restaurant and it looks fun and funky. I think it's called The Visitation. A cute name with a nod to the religious. Frederick is lacking in hotels so I'm sure it's a welcome addition.

4. The Tasting Room

4.8

Exceptional(3160)

$$$$

• Contemporary American • Frederick

Booked 22 times today

I had a wonderful experience and enjoyed every bite of food and sip of my wine sampling. This will definitely be my go-to every time I come to the area.

A photo of Table 1837 at Glen Rock Mill Inn restaurant

5. Table 1837 at Glen Rock Mill Inn

4.8

Exceptional(1490)

$$$$

• American • York

Booked 14 times today

Went there for our 32nd anniversary dinner. Best cheesecake of my life! Churro cheesecake also the best appetizer baked brie with fig, jam, and sliced pears with greens on flatbread. It was amazing. My husband loved his meal as well. He had the scallops wrapped in prosciutto. They had a little chef special tasters as well that were divine puff pastries with turkey and something wonderful. The staff was so friendly and helpful, but not in your face. First class all the way. Highly recommend.

6. Altland House

4.8

Exceptional(167)

$$$$

• American • East Berlin

Booked 7 times today

The experience at the Altland House is always very good. The restaurant was full and there appeared to be a couple of event ongoing as well which is why the noise level was a little higher then normal. Food and Service are both excellent. Reservations are recommended, especially on a weekend night.

A photo of The Barn At Allenberry restaurant

7. The Barn At Allenberry

4.6

Exceptional(2131)

$$$$

• American • Carlisle

Booked 15 times today

This was our first experience at The Barn and it was amazing. The ambience was exactly what we prefer. It was comfortable, homey and we could have sat there through the evening. The food is excellent as was the service. My husband had the venison rack which said was superb and I had the filet which was excellent. We will definitely be back. It is worth the trip.

8. Monocacy Crossing

4.8

Exceptional(3671)

$$$$

• Contemporary American • Frederick

Booked 42 times today

Every year we celebrate our anniversary at Monocacy Crossing. The food is always excellant and the staff friendly and attentive

A photo of Blackwall Barn & Lodge restaurant

9. Blackwall Barn & Lodge

4.5

Awesome(1130)

$$$$

• American • Columbia

Booked 43 times today

Andrew was an excellent server. The Manger on Sunday was amazing. That atmosphere was wonderful.

A photo of Gertrude's - Baltimore restaurant

10. Gertrude's - Baltimore

4.7

Exceptional(7325)

$$$$

• American • Charles Village

Booked 43 times today

Food was terrific. Was a quiet night (surprising) but we appreciated the service and will be back soon~

Best Cozy Restaurants in Gettysburg

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

78 restaurants available nearby

1. Mansion House 1757

2. The Smokehouse Restaurant at Antrim 1844

3. Wye Oak Tavern

4. The Tasting Room

5. Table 1837 at Glen Rock Mill Inn

6. Altland House

7. The Barn At Allenberry

8. Monocacy Crossing

9. Blackwall Barn & Lodge

10. Gertrude's - Baltimore

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable