Best Restaurants for Handcrafted Cocktails in West Sayville

This was my first time and the experience was amazing. Will definitely be back.

Valet parking. Had reservation and we were seated promptly. Our waiter was excellent. Restaurant week, we ordered off that special menu-however the sides were all extra cost (brought the bill way up since each side was approx. 15 each). We got mashed potatoes/asparagus/brussels sprouts- all excellent. Bread on table. Drinks and food were delicious. Dessert choices were nice. Not noisy and every staff member we interacted with were all very nice. If you wrap food to go -they give you a tag and when leaving you pick up your "doggie bag" at the reception area and its already in a nice bag with your tag # on it. Very classy. We will definitely be back.

My friend and I were looking for a place that was even gonna be open on industry Monday and was happy to find this venue which serves to be in between her address and my address. I’m really quite shocked that I have not yet discovered this hidden Jim, we did come at 7 o’clock in the evening, so there was just a few tables there but the ambience was very beautiful. I love the fall and Halloween decor. Our server Jamie was attentive in just the right amount. Sometimes you wonder where your server is but my girlfriend and I usually chat chat chat and never look at the menu by the time the server comes over. We’re still not ready, but it was perfectly timed. The food came out. It was delicious fresh perfect sizing price accordingly. Private parking lot all good things. I will definitely make a point of coming back here.

Great Mexican food and Margaritas. Try the frozen Prickly Pear :)

This is off season time and the weather outside wasn’t great but that didn’t spoil the view and ambience of the place. The service was great and so was the food. Anthony was our server and he was amazing. Definitely going to be hitting up Nicky’s on the bay again and can’t wait to do so during the spring and summer months.