Key Colony Beach Restaurants
Make a free reservation
Find the right table in Key Colony Beach
Find the right table in Key Colony Beach
Let OpenTable find the best spots for you.
Powered by AI
See what locals rave about in Key Colony Beach
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- JJohnAtlanta •6 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoAppetizer and salads were awesome. Filet done perfectly and braised short ribs delicious. Would definitely recommend.More infoMahina$$$$• Pacific Rim• Marathon•4.5
- LLaurieGoldKey West / Florida Keys •12 reviews5.0Dined 6 days agoWe had a great evening at FL Lobster & Steak House. Our reservation requested a table we enjoy and a waiter, Billy we always ask for, both requests were the start of a great dinner. There were 5 of us, and we all enjoyed meals our different meals of shrimp fra diablo, grilled shrimp, steak & potatoes, sushi rolls and a tuna poke bowl, along with fresh crisp salads. The menu has something for everyone and no one was disappointed, great food all around. Billy is an outstanding waiter and keep us all happy throughout the meal too. No complaints just compliments.More infoFlorida Keys Steak & Lobster House$$$$• Seafood• Marathon•4.5
- SStaffordGoldNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 22, 2026Lovely late evening meal with a live band. Would definitely recommend and will be back.More infoHavana Jack's Oceanside Restaurant & Bar$$$$• American• Key Colony Beach•3.7
- MMichaelGoldVirginia •10 reviews4.0Dined on Oct 14, 2026Plaza Grill was recommended by our hotel and it was great. Many places on the Keys are touristy and don't need to try very hard since they have a great location but Plaza Grill was awesome. We went there for an anniversary dinner and the food and service were outstanding. We had the clams but since my wife cannot have wine the chef made it with extra chicken broth and garlic. This was outstanding. The service was also great. If I had to say something negative it is that the interior was a little dated and dark but that did not keep us from enjoying a great dinner.More infoPlaza Grill$$$$• Steakhouse• Marathon•4.7
- MMikeCleveland / Akron / Canton •7 reviews5.0Dined on Jul 5, 2026Service and food have improved. Music incredible! Love the Lieder band.More infoBlu Bistro$$$$• Mediterranean• Marathon•3.9
Discover Key Colony Beach
The town of Key Colony Beach offers the traveler a choice of restaurants for oceanside dining and more. American Caribbean cuisine with the laid-back feeling of the Keys attracts visitors who enjoy a tiki bar. You can go fishing, and then cook your catch in the ultimate fresh seafood experience. Steamed clams and mussels delight some diners, while Key West Cilantro Lime Chicken is another favorite. In the area you can also find Chicago-style pizza, New York cheesecake and, of course, Key Lime Pie, a specialty of the region. You can also enjoy such classics as steak and pasta for a simple dinner. For seafood lovers, try fish tacos, fried conch, conch fritters, and New Brunswick scallops.
Explore OpenTable
- Sea Dog Charters
- Bonefish Bay Motel
- 238 Tarpon
- Glunz Ocean Beach Hotel and Suites
- 204 Oceanview Casa
- Key Colony Beach Golf and Tennis
- 236 Bonefish
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Marathon
- Abyss Dive Center
- Curry Hammock State Park
- 15 Coco Plum Beach access
- Captain Hooks Marina and Dive Center
- Floating Sea Cove Resort and Marina
- 1758 Palm Point
- 240 MahiMahi
- A Deep Blue Dive Center
- Home
- United States
- Key West / Florida Keys
