Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo

Sheepshead Bay Restaurants

Make a free reservation

Find the right table in Sheepshead Bay

Let OpenTable find the best spots for you.

Powered by AI

    See what locals rave about in Sheepshead Bay

    From verified diners like you
    From verified diners like you
    • KathyGold
      New York City •75 reviews
      5.0
      Dined 5 days ago
      Once again, fabulous dining experience. Michael’s is one of our favorite restaurants. We were a party of 4 celebrating a 90th birthday! We had a new server, John. He was very attentive. We enjoyed everything from start to finish. Would recommend eggplant polpette Parmigiana, rigatoni baked and burnt, chicken rollatini, pappardelle with mushrooms in a cream sauce, veal parmigiana, & shrimp parmigiana…save room for dessert affogato with Desoranno and the lobster tail. We’ll definitely be back very soon❤️
      More info
      Michael's of Brooklyn$$$$• Italian• Midwood
      •
      4.9
    • Shanese
      2 reviews
      5.0
      Dined on Oct 25, 2026
      One of the best Halal place to go and have a nice romantic dinner in Brooklyn. 10/10 recommend.
      More info
      GOSHT$$$$• Steakhouse• Brighton Beach
      •
      4.5
    • Andrew
      New York City •1 review
      5.0
      Dined on Oct 9, 2026
      Our first time at Level and it was a great dinner. We brought our 1.5-year-old and the staff handled it without missing a beat: attentive, patient, and quick to help with the little one. That alone would earn a return visit. Food was excellent. The seared salmon with green orzo was cooked perfectly, and the ingredients felt fresh and well sourced. The room is stunning, all chandeliers and velvet, but the noise level stayed comfortable for a family table. Food 5, service 5, ambiance 5. Will be back.
      More info
      Level Restaurant & Bar$$$$• European• Sheepshead Bay
      •
      4.6
    • mariam
      New York City •3 reviews
      5.0
      Dined on Sep 27, 2026
      Authentic Georgian flavors, warm hospitality, and a feeling of home that never fades-A little taste of Georgia in my New York life. 🇬🇪❤️
      More info
      GUDA$$$$• Georgian• Sheepshead Bay
      •
      4.8
    • JosephGold
      New York City •55 reviews
      5.0
      Dined on Sep 5, 2026
      I’ve never had a bad meal here and the service is always very good.
      More info
      Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay$$$$• Italian• Sheepshead Bay
      •
      4.6

    Restaurant experiences trending in New York City

    Frequently asked questions

    Explore OpenTable

    1. Home
    2. United States
    3. New York City
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Cookie Preferences
    Copyright © 2026 OpenTable Australia Level 22, 357 Collins Street, Melbourne, Victoria - All rights reserved.
    OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
    Booking Logo
    Priceline Logo
    KAYAK Logo
    Agoda Logo
    OpenTable Logo