Diners' Choice: Neighborhood gem restaurants in Amsterdam

OpenTable

Updated November 05, 2026

Looking for the best restaurants that are the best neighborhood gems in Amsterdam? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Shakerato

4.9

4.9 (25)

€31 to €50

Cocktail Bar

Oud-West

About the restaurant

Shakerato is a bar/restaurant featuring a selection of our iconic cocktails in a warm and intimate atmosphere. It is the second venue of world renowned bar Handshake Speakeasy, which is located in Mexico.

Reservation Duration:
Reservations last for 1 hour and 30 minutes to enjoy our unique atmosphere.

Reservation Policies:
The maximum number of guests per reservation is 12 people. For groups of 6 or more, reservations are managed exclusively by email at info@shakerato.bar
A grace period of 15 minutes is allowed; after this time, the reservation will be marked as a “no-show.”

WE DO NOT HAVE A PHONE NUMBER

Top review

SharonGold

Dined on Oct 15, 2026

Fantastic experience! Food, drinks, service, all of it was perfect!

Restaurant Heemelrijck De Pijp

4.9

4.9 (55)

€30 and under

Dutch

De Pijp

Top review

molly

Dined 4 days ago

impressed experience with dilicious food and the service is good too

Restaurant Heemelrijck Leidseplein

4.7

4.7 (50)

€30 and under

Dutch

Leidseplein

Top review

FluryGold

Dined on Oct 25, 2026

Staff was outstanding...5 Star !! Well worth the visit

Van Speyk

4.7

4.7 (483)

€31 to €50

Dutch

Binnenstad/Burgwallen

About the restaurant

VAN SPEYK is a Amsterdam style Brasserie, situated in a building from 1659 in the the old warehouse district, between the Dam square and the Grand Central Station.

Van Speyk combines Classic French flavours with Traditional Dutch influences in a intimate, romantic setting
with crystal chandeliers, candle light and high ceilings.

Enjoy icons like crisp oysters and Champagne, fresh seafood and excellent meats.

Our staff is more than willing to help you make your dinner a great experience, accompanied by good wine and friendly service.

Open: Monday till Sunday from 17.30 till midnight ( kitchen until 10:00 pm ).

Top review

david

Dined on Oct 13, 2026

Wonderful restaurant!! The service and food were great!

Restaurant Black

4.7

4.7 (80)

€30 and under

Steak

Oosterdokseiland

About the restaurant

Experience unparalleled quality and exceptional service in a picturesque setting that will leave you breathless – welcome to BLACK Amsterdam!
While our esteemed counterparts, Black & Blue and Bistro Brasserie Bleu, excel in signature steaks and beloved classics from the French cuisine, our third culinary masterpiece, BLACK Amsterdam, offers the perfect fusion of both worlds! Nestled in the heart of the charming Jordaan neighborhood, it embodies the true essence of Amsterdam.

Begin your day with a revitalizing shot of caffeine prepared by our cheerful baristas. Indulge in a tantalizingly crispy croque monsieur during your lunch break. Or savor the freshness of our succulent prawns, juicy steaks, vibrant salads, and even a delectable seafood platter for a memorable dinner! Rest assured, we cater to every dietary preference, be it vegan, vegetarian, gluten-free, or for the avid gastronome.

Top review

TeresaGold

Dined on Oct 22, 2026

I enjoyed the restaurant very much and they were very accommodating in re preparing my steak to rare, as it was brought well. Servers were friendly, and the seating was comfortable. Overall, enjoyed my dinner.

Il Pacioccone

4.6

4.6 (196)

€31 to €50

Italian

Binnenstad/Burgwallen

About the restaurant

At Il Pacioccone Amsterdam, you’ll find an authentic slice of Italy in the heart of the city. Our restaurant embodies the essence of a true Umbrian-Tuscan trattoria, where every detail reflects the authenticity and tradition of Italian cuisine.

The dishes we serve pay homage to the rich culinary heritage of central Italy, crafted with high-quality ingredients imported directly from Italy. Every flavor comes to life, offering an authentic and traditional experience.

To enhance your culinary journey, we offer an exclusive selection of fine wines, carefully chosen from small producers in Umbria and Tuscany, perfectly paired with our dishes.

From the moment you step in, you’ll be transported to the heart of Italy, savoring not just the food but also the unique atmosphere of a true Italian experience. We look forward to delighting you with the authenticity of Il Pacioccone!

*Please note: We do not serve pizza at the restaurant, but our pizzeria next door offers a full selection.

Top review

Dave

Dined on Oct 29, 2026

Extremely authentic Italian restaurant with amazing food. The menu, while perhaps limited, changes daily and contains very delicious options. The atmosphere is perfect.

Discover more

Experience

NYE DINNER 2027 - 1ST TURN

Experience

NYE GALA DINNER 2027 - TILL THE NEW YEAR!

Restaurant Heemelrijck Centrum

4.6

4.6 (32)

€30 and under

Dutch

Grachtengordel

About the restaurant

Back in time! Heemelrijck Centrum, located at Singel 161 is a smaller version of our restaurant on the beautiful Van Woustraat. The family recipes developed since 1949 are being revived here with typical Dutch dishes like pea soup, braised meat and mashed potatoes and our award winning 'Flippin Bitch'.

Top review

Sarah

Dined 4 days ago

This is a cozy restaurant with good food. We enjoyed our meal.

DAY'S StoneGrill 1870

4.4

4.4 (169)

€30 and under

Steakhouse

Grachtengordel

About the restaurant

DAY'S StoneGrill 1870 is a steakhouse where you can go for lunch and dinner. The pieces of meat come from all over the world, such as Argentina, New Zealand and Canada. The menu specializes in grill dishes and also has dishes with burgers, pizzas, pastas and chicken. You can choose a side dish with every entree from DAY'S StoneGrill 1870, such as French fries, rice or vegetables. At DAY'S StoneGrill 1870's bar, all kinds of beer, wines and spirits such as vodka, rum and whiskeys are served. Here you have the option to grill as in 1870. We prepare all meat dishes perfectly from the kitchen and you can grill it at the table. If it's a nice, sunny day, you can enjoy your meal outside on the covered patio.

Top review

TalGold

Dined on Sep 29, 2026

Lovely dinner, service was really good and food was delicious

Ferilli's Caffè Ristorante

4.4

4.4 (585)

€31 to €50

Italian

Amsterdam-Zuid

About the restaurant

MEET THE FERILLI'S AN AMSTERDAM BASED FAMILY WITH ROMAN ROOTS "THE FERILLI FAMILY " AFTER YEARS OF PLAYING A PART IN FASHION RETAIL AND SOME SIDE PROJECTS IN THE F&B SCENE IN 2016 WE STARTED BUILDING THE HOSPITALITY WORLD OF FERILLI'S. Allow us to share with you our policies: Dress Code: Our dress code is smart casual. Sportswear, beachwear, and shorts are not permitted. Gentlemen are kindly asked to avoid (sports)caps and open-toed shoes. Group Bookings: For reservations above 6 guests, please contact our team at reservation@ferillis-uptown.nl & reservation@ferilliscaffe.nl

Top review

Ricardo

Dined 6 days ago

Excellent Italian dinner on our last evening in Amsterdam. The dishes were full of flavour, the portions generous and the staff made us feel very welcome. Cosy setting and great value. We will definitely come back.

Café Americain

4.0

4 (117)

€30 and under

International

Leidseplein

About the restaurant

Café Americain is a classic grand café in Amsterdam and has been a beloved meeting place for artists, writers, and culture lovers for decades. Located in the heart of Leidseplein, our iconic Art Deco restaurant offers beautiful views of the square and combines historic elegance with contemporary refinement.

Enjoy breakfast, lunch, dinner, drinks, cocktails, or our delightful Afternoon Tea, featuring classic Amsterdam flavors and the finest Dutch ingredients. Our Chef's menu is perfect before a visit to the DeLaMar Theatre or Stadsschouwburg.

Café Americain is also the perfect venue for groups and private dining. From business meetings and corporate drinks to private events and exclusive restaurant buy-outs, we offer stylish options for every occasion.

Special offer: enjoy 20% off Afternoon Tea in September and October.

For group and private dining enquiries: reservations@cafeamericain.nl

Top review

Peter

Dined on Oct 15, 2026

Fabulous venue. Wonderful food. Superb atmosphere. Highly recommended for anyone looking for somewhere a little bit different but also quite special. Thank you.

Discover more

Experience

Breakfast

Experience

Christmas Afternoon Tea

Experience

Dinner

Explore Diners' Choice best of Amsterdam